National Council of Provinces - 17 February 2005
THURSDAY, 17 FEBRUARY 2005 __
PROCEEDINGS OF THE NATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROVINCES
____
The Council met at 15:03.
The Deputy Chairperson took the Chair and requested members to observe a moment of silence for prayers or meditation.
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS – see col 000.
ANNOUNCEMENT
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Order, please! I would like to welcome everyone back to the National Council of Provinces after the festive season, and I wish you belated greetings for the festive season.
Hon members, I would like to announce that Ms A N Mchunu and Ms N F Mazibuko were appointed to fill the vacancies that had occurred in the delegations from KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng respectively. The two members were sworn in in the Chairperson’s boardroom on 8 December
- I would like to take this opportunity to welcome the hon members. [Applause.] NOTICES OF MOTION
Mr M A MZIZI: Chairperson, I hereby give notice that on the next sitting day I shall move on behalf of the IFP:
That the Council –
(1) notes with sadness and shock that a 68-year-old female patient
was shot dead in Rietvlei Hospital near Umzimkhulu in the Eastern
Cape earlier this week, and that in a separate incident a nurse
was stabbed to death at Mokopane Hospital in Limpopo the week
before;
(2) calls upon the relevant authorities to investigate these
incidents thoroughly so that the perpetrators are brought to book;
(3) acknowledges that the security measures in state hospitals needs
to be reviewed urgently so that similar incidents can be avoided
in future; and
4) offers its deepest condolences to the families of the deceased.
Mr A WATSON: Hon Chairperson, I give notice that I shall move at the next sitting of the House: That the Council –
(1) notes the results of a by-election held in Evander, Ward
18 of the Govan Mbeki Municipality in Mpumalanga on 26 January
2005, and congratulates the DA on a resounding victory over
the ANC and FF Plus, in that the DA achieved 76% of the vote,
the ANC 22% and the FF Plus a mere 2%; and
(2) further notes that this achievement represents a technical
regain for the DA in that the ANC garnered a majority of 55%
of the vote in this ward during the April 2004 elections.
MOTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
FIELD RANGER ATTACKED BY CROCODILE
(Draft Resolution)
Mrs J N VILAKAZI: Madam Deputy Chair, I move without notice:
That the Council –
(1) notes that on 13 February 2005, while crossing the Black
Umfolozi River in KwaZulu-Natal, Field Ranger E Ngcobo was
attacked and pulled down by a large crocodile;
(2) further notes that Field Ranger S Nxumalo, who was accompanying
Field Ranger Ngcobo, bravely attacked the crocodile and pulled the
victim to shore and then proceeded to perform basic first aid
before Field Ranger Ngcobo was airlifted to hospital;
(3) also notes that Field Ranger Ngcobo is in a stable condition but
that his left hand had to be amputated as it was badly injured;
(4) wishes him a speedy and full recovery; and
(5) congratulates Field Ranger S Nxumalo for his extreme bravery in
saving his colleague from certain death.
Motion agreed to in accordance with section 65 of the Constitution.
VISIT TO MPUMALANGA
(Draft Resolution)
The CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP: Thank you, Deputy Chairperson of the Council, I wish to move the Draft Resolution in my name that notwithstanding Rule (21)(2)(c), the Council in terms of Rule 21(2) resolves that in the interest of enhancing public participation as provided for in section 72(1)(a) and (b) of the Constitution of the Republic of South Africa, Act 108 of 1996, as from 14-18 March 2005, the Council will conduct public hearings, hold meetings and conduct oversight visits in Mpumalanga. The NCOP will sit in plenary on 18 March 2005 from approximately 10h00 until the conclusion of the business. I so move.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): As there is no speakers’ list, I shall now put the question. The question is that the motion be agreed to as the decision is dealt with in terms of section 65 of the Constitution.
I shall first ascertain whether all the delegation heads are present in the Chamber to cast their province’s votes. Are all the delegation heads present? Yes.
Question put.
Mr A WATSON: On a point of clarity, I’ve heard the motion and we will not object to it, as is our right, but it’s the second visit and it’s a very important visit. May I just enquire why have we for the second time waived Rule 21(2)(c) which determines that the costs of such a visit should be ascertained.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): In accordance with Rule 71, I shall first allow provinces the opportunity to make their declarations of vote, if they so wish. We shall continue.
We shall now proceed to voting on the question. I shall do this in alphabetical order per province. Delegation heads must please indicate to the Chair whether they vote in favour, or against or abstain from voting.
Mr A Watson: On a point of order, Madam Chair: My question was not replied to or even acknowledged.
The CHIEF WHIP OF THE COUNCIL: Thank you very much, hon Deputy Chair, but this matter has been discussed and deliberated upon more than several times in the multiparty Whips’ meetings, in the Programming Committee meetings, where all parties sit, and have a say. It is not the first time that it has been raised. We have even gone into further detail than the actual amounts in terms of the visit to Mpumalanga.
So, though, I don’t blame the member for not receiving the information from the respective or relevant party representatives who are supposed to report back to their caucuses - I’ll not blame him for his ignorance when he comes to this House ignorant of that fact - the matter however has been deliberated upon more than several times. Thank you, Deputy Chair.
Mr A WATSON: Thank you. I object to being called ignorant; I get the minutes of all the Programme Committee meetings and in none of them - and I get reports of the Whips’ meetings - was any amount in terms of this visit mentioned. So, I really ask that the Chief Whip withdraw the remark that I am ignorant otherwise I will accuse him of misleading the House.
The CHIEF WHIP OF THE COUNCIL: My simple understanding of English is that if a person doesn’t have information, he or she is ignorant.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Thank you, sir. We shall now continue. Eastern Cape?
Mr A WATSON: May I ask your ruling on that, Madam Chair.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): I rule you out of order. Thank you. Mr Watson, will you please sit.
We shall proceed. Eastern Cape?
Ms B N DLULANE: Siyaxhasa. [We support.]
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Free State?
Mr T S SETONA: In favour.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Gauteng?
Mr E M SOGONI: Siyaxhasa. [We support.]
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): KwaZulu-Natal?
Mr Z C NTULI: KwaZulu-Natal supports.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP: Limpopo?
Ms H F MATLANYANE: Limpopo re a thega. [Limpopo supports.]
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP: Mpumalanga?
Ms M P THEMBA: Mpumalanga supports.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Northern Cape?
Mr K SINCLAIR: In favour.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): North West?
Mr Z S KOLWENI: Ke a rona. [Supports.]
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Western Cape?
Mr F ADAMS: Wes-Kaap steun. [Western Cape supports.]
Motion agreed to in accordance with section 65 of the Constitution.
CONSIDERATION OF REPORT ON KWAZULU-NATAL VISIT
The CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP: Madam Deputy Chair, I thank you for the opportunity given to me to participate in this debate. As you would be aware, last year on 30 June 2004 we had approved what we call a programme of action called Vision 2000. In that programme we committed ourselves to that most of our time and most of our resources will be pledged to our oversight role; and the NCOP is going to proceed with that vision or programme of action precisely because that is the work we are called upon to do and the programme has to succeed.
Since 1994, during this first decade of our democracy, Parliament has passed quite a number of laws that seek to transform society and ensure that the change in the lives of our people is being met or made better.
Now, at the end of the beginning of the second decade our democratic Parliament should focus and ensure that instruments that we have put in place actually benefit the people on the ground. This is why we need to focus on the monitoring and implementation of these policies of government programmes in order to speed up delivery to our people, more especially those who stay in the rural areas and squatter settlements.
I think it is our duty as a House that we should go out there and do that. Our imperative therefore is to ensure that our people, wherever they find themselves, benefit from the positive changes that are taking place in our country.
The NCOP has certain programmes and activities that assist us to fulfil oversight roles. This includes community work that we normally undertake from time to time. It includes provincial visits and also public involvement initiatives, amongst other things. In the area of public involvement, our mainstay programme of taking Parliament to the people will continue to serve as a key element in our strategy of promoting popular participation in the affairs of Parliament and government. As a result we will continue to ensure that the NCOP uses this programme as a platform for our people to air their opinions to Parliament.
Because of the skewed distribution of resources amongst our people, as a result our racist past, one will find many of our people still being unable to interact directly with the institutions that support democracy. Parliament remains accessible mainly to those who have the resources to travel to Cape Town or Parliament. We will not allow this to disadvantage our people who do not have the necessary resources to do so.
Now, through the programme of taking Parliament to the people, we are to listen to the ideas of the people on the ground, their comments and suggestions that are made to us. In this way they do not have to wait for us to see them at a later stage, but we interact with them even during these periods of our sitting in Parliament.
Our programme of taking Parliament to the people was launched, as you would know, in 2002 when we went to the Eastern Cape. We went to North West last and last year we went KwaZulu-Natal, and the report I’m getting is that the people on the ground are very happy about this programme.
I was speaking to a number of radio stations yesterday, for a whole hour, and everyone who called in commended the taking of Parliament to the people. It’s becoming one of the vehicles that really makes us interact very effectively with the people on the ground.
Now coming to the subject for today, a visit to KwaZulu-Natal, I just want to mention a few things. I will allow other people also to participate in this debate through the speakers list.
Our programme in KwaZulu-Natal focused on some of the important issues in the development of genuine equality in the country. These include education, promotion of agriculture, social development, the youth, women, people with disabilities as well as local government. This afternoon’s debate provides an opportunity to look at the issues raised during the visit to Empangeni and the surrounding areas. It also provides us with the opportunity to look at trends with regard to service delivery and the challenges that our provinces are facing.
As we roll out our programme to more and more provinces, we should be able to look at such trends and begin to come up with proactive mechanisms to assist provinces that are facing similar challenges. This programme must have the required impact to change the lives of our people on the ground. Our committee therefore has the responsibility to identify issues particularly in this report that is being presented before us today, that relate to the portfolios and come up with tangible plans to solve those problems.
It is important that as a House we provide space for the review of the programme report to see what kind of impact we are making. We must see in what way we have been able to address the challenges and issues raised by the people on the ground in KwaZulu-Natal.
Some of the important issues, which the President has raised in Empangeni, were the following: The NCOP should do an assessment on how it could enhance its role in encouraging public participation. He further said how the NCOP could play a role in accelerating the process of transformation; how to ensure through the implementation of policies that we are able to ensure that their outcomes are visualised. That’s a crucial thing and it’s not just a question of visiting and seeing what is happening, but it is a question of really visualising it so that people can see those things that we are talking about: to render its support to municipalities, build the necessary infrastructure, develop institutional capacity and systems to ensure that they discharge their constitutional mandate or constitutional obligation.
The President also expressed the need for our local government system to provide the platform for popular participation in the affairs of our local councils, as well as the need for transparency in local government structures. Through the participation in this House, we hope that the representatives of local government will, within local government, join the debate started by the President. This is very important if we are to promote a democratic and developmental local government, which empowers our people to act as their own liberators. But just to touch on the issues of education quickly, when we visited schools in KwaZulu-Natal, those who were in my delegation will agree that we have been made aware of the amount of work that still needs to be done in order to overcome some of the legacies of the past. The stories that we heard and the things that we witnessed should not make us despair, but instead should give us the energy to pursue our genre for delivery.
We have noted serious challenges facing government in the area of education in the province. These issues are a backlog in the provision of classrooms, the lack of ablution systems and water facilities, teenage pregnancies, learner drop-out and long distances that pupils have to walk to school.
While government promised to look seriously into these challenges, we should not down-play the role that parents and communities can play in coming up with a practical solution to the challenges facing these schools. For instance, issues such as vandalism and crime, which were also raised during the visits, can best be dealt with by parents and communities, together with government, in order for the communities to reclaim their schools.
In terms of agriculture, small and emerging farmers told us about the difficulties that they are experiencing in their quest to stake a claim in the cultural and farming sector. Some of these include the lack of training of new farmers, which has resulted in poor management of co-operatives and poor road infrastructure for the transportation of agricultural crops to mills and markets.
Small-scale growers also told us that the requirements of labour legislation such as minimum wages and other conditions of employment often led to the loss of jobs and other costs, which they cannot afford. We need to assist our small entrepreneurs. However, we should not allow a situation whereby the rights and dignity of workers could be undermined.
During the state of the nation address last Friday, the President expressed government’s intention to review the regulatory framework as it applies to small, medium and micro enterprises. This review is meant to bring the necessary relief to our small entrepreneurs by giving them space in which to develop.
In terms of awareness, another important aspect we have noted form our engagement with the people of KwaZulu-Natal is that it is very important for the government to create more awareness around the programmes that are designed to assist the people. While the government has got programmes to assist, for instance, women in business with access to finance and technology training, there is limited knowledge amongst women about this programme.
This is the same with regard to some of the initiatives of the various government departments. This is a challenge to us; we need to assist in making sure that the people are being made aware of the programmes provided by the government, and Members of Parliament could play a vital role in this.
We will continue to draw on the lessons that these visits provide us with as public representatives and use them to benefit our people even more. We will continue to look at issues such as corruption in the Public Service, which our people have raised during all three visits. We have already undertaken as the NCOP to view these issues in a serious light.
Public servants are there to serve the people and not to prey on them; this is an important thing. We need our select committees to be vigilant to ensure that the issues that we are picking up and those that our people are telling us about are actually followed up.
Now in terms of the future visit, in order to ensure that our programme of taking Parliament to the people becomes more effective and that we add value to our work, our programme should provide for a special session for members to discuss critical issues raised during the public meetings. They must then give direction in terms of the steps that the House should take.
From now on our programme will include special sessions for Members to debate the issues that came up during the public proceedings. We should have at least two such sessions during a week-long visit in those areas. Our report, as it stands, does not give us much in terms of the direction that the House should take. We are a political institution; and as such we need to factor in political input in our report.
These will assist our committees when they pick up the issues from the report that relates to their areas. It will also help us as a House during the review process to see whether we have been able to follow up on the things on which we said we should follow up. So, when picking up this report and reading it, one should be able to say that these are the issues that have been raised for the NCOP; they are the things that the NCOP should be doing and we must be able to ask whether have they been done, because I think that’s a very critical issue.
I want to propose to this House that the Chair of Committees should begin to put together a process where our committees, which deal with the respective issues raised in the report, must go back to KwaZulu-Natal after recess and follow-up. That is my proposition that I want to put to this House. And we must lift up those things from the report and go back to the area of Empangeni and follow up and make sure that those things are happening on the ground.
In conclusion, our visit to KwaZulu-Natal was a great success. However, we must not limit the success of a programme of this nature to how successfully it was carried out. We should measure its success by its impact on the lives of the people, because their lives must change. Our question should then be: What change has been brought to the people who came to share their stories with us? That is an important thing and that is why I am proposing that those committees should go back to KwaZulu-Natal.
In this way we will be able to see the contribution of this programme in the process of speeding up delivery and improving the quality for our lives and even making them better on the ground. Deputy Chairperson, I thank you.
Ms H F MATLANYANE: Deputy Chairperson, hon members, let me start by saying that today I dedicate my speech to the late Chairperson of the NCOP. Thank you. [Applause.]
Go tloga ka la 1 go fihla ka la 5 Nofemere 2004, setšhaba sa Empangeni se ile sa ba le boitemogelo le go kwešiša gore ke go reng ge go thwe ``The People Shall Govern!’’ Se, se diregile ge Khansele ya Bosetšhaba ya Diprofensi e be e išitše Palamente tikologong yeo gore batho ba fao ba tšeye karolo mererong ka moka yeo e amago maphelo a bona, ditlhologelo tša Freedom Charter le mmušo wo etilwego pele ke ANC, woo o hlabollago maphelo a batho ka moka le go ba hlohleletša go ba karolo ya Palamente le go kgatha tema mererong ya yona. (Translation of Sepedi paragraph follows.)
[From the 1st to the 5th of November 2004 the people of Empangeni understood what it meant when it was said that “the people shall govern”. This took place when the National Council of Provinces took Parliament to this community, so that the people of this area could participate in discussing all the matters affecting their lives, the aim of the Freedom Charter and the ANC-led government, which transforms the lives of all people and encourages them to be part of parliament and to participate in parliamentary business.]
As we need constantly to review the manner in which we have been doing things to ensure that as a movement we have a strategic response to the challenges of the next five years and the coming decade up to 2014, the words of Comrade Nelson Mandela, when he addressed CODESA on 20 December 1991 about the will of the people, are as true today as they were then. He said:
Today will be indelibly imprinted in the history of our country. If we, who are gathered here respond to the challenge before us, today will mark the commencement of the transition from apartheid to democracy. Our people, from every corner of our country, have expressed their yearning for democracy and peace. CODESA represents the historical opportunity to translate that yearning into reality . . .
South Africans of many persuasions recognize that this environment, and its constitutional product, CODESA, is the fruit of their sacrifices and struggle. They have a justifiable expectation that CODESA will set our country on the road to democracy.
It is because of that ``justifiable expectation’’ that the NCOP, amongst other things, decided that Parliament should be taken to the people, and its first port of call was KwaZulu-Natal for this third term.
This exercise was also in total acquiescence with what James Madison, once said:
Knowledge will forever govern ignorance, and people who mean to be their own governors, must arm themselves with the power which knowledge gives.
James Madison again concurs with our President, Thabo Mbeki, who during his opening address of the 51st Congress of the African National Congress in Stellenbosch said:
The people of South Africa have made the common determination that our country belongs to all who live in it, black and white. It says that the people of South Africa, black and white, are committed to live up the pledge they made to themselves, to refuse to be enslaved by the divisions and antagonisms of the past.
The principle of Taking Parliament to the People embodied, amongst other things, adherence to the clause, ``the people shall govern’’ in the Freedom Charter - whose 50th anniversary we celebrate this year.
We must also imbue in our people the vision of an alternative society to the society that we inherited. It should also be borne in mind that it is democracy that citizens should be continuously engaged in governance through interaction with those who make decisions. And, I can say with aplomb that through this ANC-led government that is continuously happening.
Having a ballot box once every few years is an important element of democracy, but it is only one step in the process of building a society that genuinely serves the interests of all its people. It is because of the fact that we have to fulfil our onerous task and commitment as members of Parliament who are elected to make laws and policies on behalf of the people that the NCOP, as required, fulfilled its mandate to consult continuously with the citizens on whose behalf we act unapologetically.
It was pleasing to note the excitement of the people and the candid interaction they had with all of us during our visit to KwaZulu-Natal in Taking Parliament to the People. It was also emotionally moving also to notice the lack of information on programmes and policies made by this government for the benefit of our people. As one of the responsibilities of the exercise was the dissemination of information to the people, it is pleasing to note that the results indicated a positive impact of the exercise on the people of the area we visited.
As processing of the identity documents was identified as a key issue during the visit, it is also pleasing to note that since the visit 40 823 identity documents were issued at 31 service points across the province from November 2004 to January 2005.
We are rather concerned about the figures provided by the Department of Home Affairs that show that at 11 other service delivery points no identity documents were issued. The reason for the major concern is that successful processing of identity documents enables our people to access child grants, but more importantly, it allows our people access to the wealth that the country has to offer. This wealth is both in terms of material wealth and, most importantly, in terms of being included in a democratic process of overseeing the implementation of policies that ensures a better life for all our people.
In addition, there were schools where children were taught under the trees. The parents have now started a programme to build three extra classrooms in one of the schools.
Baswana, ka Sepedi, ba re: Kgomo go tsošwa ye e itsošago. Batho ba KwaZulu- Natal ba itsošitše. [The old people say in Sepedi: The person who tries to help himself or herself will also get help from other people. The people of KwaZulu-Natal have tried.]
We are urging the Department of Education in the province to assist parents of that community in their efforts.
It is this new patriotism displayed by these active democrats in KwaZulu- Natal that also our President was referring to in his state of the nation address last Friday. We salute our people who show that they are ready to govern, ready to voice their feelings, ready to work as a united nation of winners in a transforming country.
We raised expectations in KwaZulu-Natal, and as we ourselves always say that a lot still needs to be done, we are proceeding to other provinces, but let us always ensure that as we go about that we make a difference, as we touch the lives of . . . [Time expired.] [Applause.]
Mr A WATSON: Hon Deputy Chairperson, allow me to start by adding my personal congratulations to that of my party to both you and our hon Chairperson on your elevation to the high office of this House. Let me pledge the fullest support of the DA in all your lawful undertakings. [Laughter.]
May I also say that I wish to start by saying that my party and my colleagues are in full support of provincial visits, and that we look forward to fully participating also in the coming visit to Mpumalanga. So please don’t see the fact of our insistence earlier today on working to the Rules as a negative observation.
The object of this debate is, however, to reflect on a week in which we, the Upper House, took Parliament to the people of KwaZulu-Natal, and let me hasten to congratulate the compilers of the report on a job well done.
Yet, whilst I have no desire to dwell on the less pleasant aspects of the visit which came to the forefront, particularly during the plenary sessions, I do think that the plenaries and particularly the subjects debated should have formed part of the report, especially in regard to the substance of those debates.
One such example is the address and reply of the hon President on 4 November 2004 because it contained a very important message which spoke directly to us as members of the NCOP, and contained no less than an instruction to spend most of our time in the provinces, and in particular, to get more involved with local government and related programmes.
If we therefore wish to reflect on our visit and our actions thereafter, we should actually contemplate our involvement in that sphere of government; a sphere that is closest to the people who elected us as their representatives; a sphere that was designed to be at the forefront of delivery and in reality the service agent of government. But alas, it is also a sphere of nondelivery and corruption which is no longer on the brink of explosion but which has indeed exploded and is burning.
Yes, indeed there was burning: Ask the people of Bronkhorstspruit, ask the people of Mpumalanga and Henneman, ask the people of Clocolan, ask the people of Siyabuswa, and so I can carry on! And why? Because that sphere of government is simply not delivering as it should be and instead of constantly working for the betterment of our people, it is a sphere that is constantly plagued by corruption and incompetence.
Dit het tyd geword, agb Voorsitter, dat ons, as die verkose verteenwoordigers, moet erken dat plaaslike regering eenvoudig nie oor genoegsame kundigheid beskik nie. Die kundiges is weggedryf en vervang deur onbevoegde amptenare en verteenwoordigers vir wie eie belang van groter waarde is as dienslewering.
Ek kan talle voorbeelde noem, waarvan die koerante ook vol is, maar kom ons kyk net vir ‘n oomblik na een voorbeeld. As ek dan lieg, Meneer . . . [Tussenwerpsels.] (Translation of Afrikaans paragraphs follows.)
[The time has come, hon Chairperson, for us, as the elected representatives, to admit that local government simply does not possesses sufficient expertise. The experts have been driven out and replaced by incompetent officials and representatives for whom self-interest is of greater value than service delivery.
I can mention numerous examples, which also appear in the newspapers, but let us look at only one example for a moment. If I am lying, sir . . . [Interjections.]]
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Are you rising on a point of order, hon member?
The CHIEF WHIP OF THE COUNCIL: No, it is not a point of order, Chair. I am rising on a point which we raise every time in this House – that one of interpretation, because there was no interpretation. I will not respond to that nonsense.
Mr A WATSON: Chair, I hope that the interpreting service has not stolen my time and that you will make provision for me to complete my speech.
Ek sê ek kan talle voorbeelde noem, waarvan die koerante ook vol is, maar kom ons kyk net vir ‘n oomblik na een voorbeeld, dié van Govan Mbeki Plaaslike Munisipaliteit - een van die drie grootste munisipaliteite in Mpumalanga.
Die munisipale bestuurder, ‘n onomwonde ondersteuner van die ANC, het pas die hoeveelste hofsaak gewen om, na die onbillike ontslag deur sy “comrade”, die burgemeester, weer in sy pos herstel te word! Die ANC- burgemeester weier egter weer volstrek om hom terug te aanvaar en het so pas opdrag gegee dat sy salaris gestaak moet word. Dit, agb Voorsitter, terwyl dieselfde burgemeester en sy ANC-raad, in opdrag van die ANC- beheerde provinsiale regering, weens talle aanklagte van ongerymdhede ondersoek word.
Waar is dienslewering dan nou daar? Nee, daar is geen teken daarvan nie en dis geen wonder dat die DA in hierdie munisipaliteit so pas ‘n wyk loshande van die ANC, in Evander, afgeneem het nie.
Ek is egter trots om te kan vermeld dat die leier van die DA en die leier van die amptelike opposisie in Mpumalanga gister aan die Premier en sy LUR ‘n skrywe gerig het om te eis dat hierdie belaglike toedrag van sake nou aangespreek kan . . . [Tussenwerpsels.] (Translation of Afrikaans paragraphs follows.)
[I am saying I that I can mention numerous examples, of which many also appear in the newspapers, but let us just look at one example for a moment, that of the Govan Mbeki Local Municipality – one of the three largest municipalities in Mpumalanga.
The municipal manager, a staunch supporter of the ANC, has just won the umpteenth court case once again to be reinstated in his post after his unfair dismissal by his comrade, the mayor! However, the ANC mayor absolutely refuses to take him back and has just given instructions that payment of his salary must be stopped. That, hon Chairperson, while the same mayor and his ANC council, at the instruction of the ANC-controlled provincial government, are being investigated because of numerous charges of irregularities.
Where is the service delivery there then? No, there is no sign of it and it is no wonder that the DA in this municipality has just taken a ward from the ANC in Evander with ease.
However, I am proud to be able to say that the leader of the DA and the leader of the official opposition in Mpumalanga yesterday wrote a letter to the Premier and his MEC to demand that this ridiculous state of affairs should now be addressed . . . [Interjections.]]
The CHIEF WHIP OF THE COUNCIL: Chair, I now have the interpretation, and I have listened carefully to what they are interpreting. The hon member is not debating on the report of KwaZulu-Natal. He is now mentioning other issues beyond that particular report. Most of the time he is always very strong on the point that we must concentrate on the subject of the matter. I think he will also do likewise. Thank you.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Please keep to the Rules, hon member.
Mr A WATSON: Madam Chair, I think I am keeping to the Rules. I am referring to the instruction given by the highest authority in this country – the President of this country – that we must get involved in local government and get it right. That is what I am now talking about – the local government and service delivery that is not taking place. So, that is not the object of the point of my . . . [Interjections.]
The CHIEF WHIP OF THE COUNCIL: Chairperson, you don’t use the instruction of the highest authority opportunistically. The debate is about KwaZulu- Natal, and not about all the other things the hon member wants to talk about. Thank you.
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Order! You may continue, hon member.
Mnr A WATSON: Ek het gesê ek is egter trots om te kan vermeld dat die leier van die DA ‘n skrywe aan die Premier gerig en gevra het dat die vraag opgelos moet word. Dis nie ‘n vraag of daar probleme is nie, agb Voorsitter. Die vraag is: Wat is die rol van die Nasionale Raad van Provinsies? Watter rol moet ons vervul om die probleem op te los?
Die opdrag van die President was baie duidelik. Die taak is voorhande. Maar as die ANC nie die wil het om te luister na die probleme nie asook nie oor die vermoë beskik om die probleem op te los nie, dan sal die DA maar die pad aanwys. Ek dank u. [Applous.] (Translation of Afrikaans paragraphs follows.)
[Mr A WATSON: I said that I was nevertheless proud to be able to mention that the leader of the DA had written a letter to the Premier asking that the problem should be solved. It is not a question of whether there are problems, hon Chairperson. The question is: What is the role of the National Council of Provinces? What role must we play to solve the problem?
The instructions of the President are quite clear. The task is clear. But if the ANC neither has the will to listen to the problems nor possess the ability to solve the problem, then the DA will just show the way. I thank you. [Applause.]]
Mnr F ADAMS: Voorsitter, Adjunkvoorsitter, agb lede, laat my toe om gelukwensing uit te spreek. My party het dit reeds gedoen. Ek wil beide die Voorsitter en u, die Adjunkvoorsitter, gelukwens met u verkiesing om hierdie Huis te lei. Voorsitter, ek weet julle is bekwame mense en ons weet ons is in bekwame hande. Ek sidder net om te dink as die DA ooit eendag die Huis moet lei, want dan weet ek nie wat sal gebeur nie. Dan sal ons vergaan! (Translation of Afrikaans paragraph follows.) [Mr F ADAMS: Chairperson, Deputy Chairperson, hon members, allow me to convey my congratulations. My party has done so already. I want to congratulate both the Chairperson and you, Deputy Chairperson, on your election to the leadership of this House. Chairperson, I know that you are competent people and we know that we are in competent hands. I shudder just to think about the DA ever leading this House, because I do not know what will happen then. We shall perish then!]
The DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON OF THE NCOP (Ms P Hollander): Order! Thank you.
Mr F ADAMS: Chairperson, the year 2004 was the end of a decade of freedom and democracy. The theme of taking Parliament to the people in KwaZulu- Natal was celebrating unity in diversity. The first decade of freedom and democracy has demonstrated the capacity and willingness of our people, drawn from all sectors and all races, to act together and confront the national challenges that we face.
I quote from the speech of our President, Thabo Mbeki, on 5 November 2004 in KwaZulu-Natal:
A matter on which we are all concentrating is the issue of the acceleration of the process of transformation, focusing on the objectives of a better life for all our people and improving, as quickly as possible, the quality of life for all our people.
Not just simply a few people like the DA, but all our people. The central challenge that we face from the report is the task of implementation. As the President also said in KwaZulu-Natal, we all know that there are many problems in our country that we have not solved. It is going to take us some time to solve them. We must continue, as we begin our second decade of liberation, to commit ourselves to doing everything possible to push back the frontiers of poverty and expand access to a better life for all, to realise the people-centred process we have to achieve.
I want to thank the Presiding Officers, the Secretary, and all the staff members of the NCOP as well as the researchers for such a comprehensive report and for the programme we had in KwaZulu-Natal. Our cluster 4, under the chairmanship of the Rev Peter Moatshe and the hon member Raseriti Johannes Tau, is going back to Empangeni to do a follow-up, as we have been instructed and as it is expected of us. I want to conclude with a quote from the Freedom Charter:
We pledge ourselves to strive together, sparing neither strength nor courage until the democratic change, as set out, has been won.
[Applause.]
Mrs L G NGCOBO (KwaZulu-Natal): Madam Chair, it’s my great pleasure to come here and voice the feelings of our legislature and possibly of the people of KwaZulu-Natal after the NCOP’s visit to our province late last year.
We are very happy that they were able to present the face of Parliament to the people as they live their lives, and to draw them closer to the programmes and aims of Parliament at national level. Of course, this has raised great hopes among the people of that region. Of course, I will emphasise that it is the people of that region, because the people who have really benefited are the people of the Empangeni region. One wonders, from where we are, whether we are going to be able to reach the rest of the province and be able to do also for all of them what has been done for the people of Empangeni.
As the Chairman of the NCOP has mentioned, we specifically looked at the schools on that occasion. The problem of the shortage of classrooms – which, more or less, is found in every part of the province – and the shortage of teachers are things that are drawing back our progress in this area. However, I’m also happy to acknowledge here that it is not all gloom and doom in that many of the schools that suffer these disabilities are, in fact, doing very well.
In that report we have at least one school, and we know many more, that’s been able to actually get a pass rate of 100%. So, I have all the admiration for them and I want to mention here that our people are in great difficulties and we are doing all we can to make things better, but many of our people are doing their best and we should, at this kind of platform, acknowledge that. I’m happy to be able to acknowledge it, as indicated in the report.
They suffer a lot of inconveniences, such as the lack of toilets; there is a lot of crime and abuses and we, in our province, are experiencing a wave of drug peddling, which is affecting our schools. I would wish our government to pay a lot of attention to this problem while perhaps we can still manage to control it. Durban, being a port, seems to be a very attractive area for the dispersing and the sale of these drugs, and the drugs are getting into our schools and are beginning to be a real concern in our schools.
Another area that impressed me very much on those visits was the visit to the women’s projects. Many of them are encouraging. We are going to need a lot of money to try and give them the necessary tools with which to progress in their programmes, and they need a lot of knowledge. Those are some of the things that I’m hoping these undertakings will provide for the women.
We are also hoping to benefit from the legislation that is the battery of the various laws that we have passed in the last few years, although some of them have not yet really penetrated the fabric of life in our province. I think there is a step that we are missing. We are unable, at this point, to actually make these laws acceptable and user-friendly to the women, and perhaps Parliament could take this as a challenge. [Time expired.] [Applause.]
Mr M A MZIZI: Sihlalo, ake ngigcwalisele nami ekukubongeleni ngesikhundla owenyulelwe kuso. Ngiyazi iqembu lami lakuhalalisela kodwa asigcwalise nje ukuthi-ke siyakuhalalisela ngokuthi wenyukele kuleso sikhundla. [Chairperson, let me also add my congratulations to you on your appointment to this position. I am aware that my party has congratulated you already on your appointment, but let me also congratulate you on your promotion to this position.]
Getting down to the business: Deputy Chairperson and hon members, the report tabled before us is but a part of an ongoing programme. The purpose envisaged was to take Parliament to the people. KwaZulu-Natal was a very fortunate province to experience such an opportunity and have the first bite of the cake. The reason why I say this is because, among other things, the plenary sittings did take place and some of the Bills were debated and passed in that plenary.
The Council was engaged in various activities. It was engaged in consultations at its imbizos, where people had to put questions directly to the national Ministers as well as the MECs. The Council visited various areas, including schools and other institutions.
If I could elaborate on the visit to schools, this was part of an initiative to ensure that no learner will be educated under a tree. It is unfortunate that approximately 6 000 schools are in poor condition. Over 90% of these schools are in the rural areas.
The IFP welcomes the move the Premier of KwaZulu-Natal, uMazankosi Sbu Ndebele, has made at Copesville, where he suggested the use of prefab slabs to build a school. Well done. We applaud that. However, this was the idea of the erstwhile KwaZulu-Natal government. They engaged themselves in encouraging the people to build schools by various methods. If this project of prefab slabs could be community-driven, the Extended Public Works Programme would eventually be seen getting off the ground and eradicating poverty.
In conclusion, I must say that some of the things seen during the various visits . . .
. . . zazinyantisa umzimba kodwa ngoba lokhu umbiko wezinto esazibona, kunethemba lokuthi umbono ophelele ngezimo ezimbi ezabonakala nokho ezinye zazo izinto ezingakwazi ukuthi zilungiswe maduze. Ngoba isikhathi asikho, Sihlalo ngizokongela nje isikhashana esincane. Siyabonga. Angigeqi magula angemuki. [Ihlombe.] (Translation of isiZulu paragraph follows.)
[. . . although such things were not good for sensitive people, but that was a report of what was observed. We hope that a complete picture of the bad events that were observed would emerge, and that some of them would be rectifiable soon. Chairperson, due to a lack of time I shall save you a little time. Thank you. I am not going to say much. [Applause.]]
Mr D D GAMEDE: Thank you, Chairperson. Allow me firstly to add my voice in congratulating both you and the Chairperson in your appointments to lead this institution, the NCOP. Secondly, I am not surprised that the hon Watson had nothing to say about the KwaZulu-Natal visit, because he has nothing to say. One cannot say something if one hasn’t got anything to say.
The concept of taking Parliament to the people has been, and still is, the culture and tradition of the ANC. The visit of the ANC to KwaZulu-Natal was therefore the reaping of the fruits of the struggles waged by our people and their insistence that the ANC must govern. It was and it is still only the ANC that could deliver.
This visit proved that prior to 1994 sectors such as women, youth, children, and people with disabilities, were not catered for. This year, as well as the NCOP’s visit to KwaZulu-Natal, only serve to endorse the Freedom Charter and the fact that South Africa belongs to all who live in it. Hence this year we celebrate the adoption of the Freedom Charter, which was adopted at the Congress of the People in Kliptown on the 26 June 1955.
On sectoral meetings, in particular meetings with women, a lot was achieved. We witnessed the success of the sight visit of Phezukwemkhono Women’s Co-op, which seized the opportunities provided by the government. Structures and institutions have been set up by this government to improve the quality of women. There are quite a number of opportunities that are now available for women. However, there are still some major challenges in this regard, such as implementing government policies that must be monitored by our committees, as it has been alluded to.
Some of the shortcomings that were identified in this sector were education and training, economic empowerment and participation in all structures. On the issue of the youth sector, in this sector a number of challenges were identified by the youth. These challenges include monitoring resources earmarked for the youth, interference in youth programmes, fees at tertiary institutions and access to funds.
One of the clauses of the Freedom Charter provides that the doors of learning and culture shall be open. Hence this government has established the student financial aid scheme to assist needy students. The students of KwaZulu-Natal have made use of this opportunity. Generally the young people in KwaZulu-Natal from all corners showed that they have confidence in this government.
On people with disabilities, key areas were identified, such as accessibility to roads, structures and transport, education and training, and economic development. A lot of progress has been made in this sector, starting from the adoption of the government’s Integrated National Disability Strategy. This sector noted a huge change in government policies and the inclusion of all different types of people with disabilities in all government departments and spheres. This really proves that all are now equal.
A site visit to Jabulani Craft Centre, which the Deputy Chairperson of this House also attended, showed that there are still a few crumbs of the old regime who are still hell-bent on sticking to the past, and are still exploiting the poor and especially those with physical disabilities. However, this government is doing its best to attend to the situation.
The site visit to Amangwe village, which was one of the success stories of the private-public partnership and the government’s programme of caring for the sick, especially those people affected and infected by HIV/Aids, uncovers the clause, “ there shall be peace and friendship”. That really showed that when there is friendship among people, there is also caring. The government’s food parcel programme is also highly appreciated, even though there are challenges and one is that it is being used as a political stick in certain areas.
The meeting with farmers, which has been alluded to, really proved that the people shall share in the country’s wealth. Farmers were happy and supportive of the government’s programmes such as developing SMEs, liming and salt fertilising, dam building, eradication of alien weeds, and many more.
All these programmes create thousands of job opportunities. Generally the challenges in these sectors were access to finance and infrastructure, which would include roads. These challenges are being faced head on.
In conclusion, Chair, the NCOP visit to KwaZulu-Natal, for the people of KwaZulu-Natal, was an eye opener for all of them, even for certain members of this House. The mandate that the people of KwaZulu-Natal gave to the ANC, and South Africa generally, is enough proof that only the ANC has got policies that can advance the struggle for the total elimination of all the backlogs.
President Thabo would say that the people have spoken. And I am therefore proud to say that the people of KwaZulu-Natal have spoken. They have said: Viva NCOP! They are proud to say that if they notice something they will report it to the NCOP. [Applause]. They don’t mind saying, even though it is painful: “Sit down, Mr Watson” or, in memory of the late Comrade Joyce Kgoali, “the people shall govern!” I thank you, Chair. [Applause.]
Rev E ADOLPH: Thank you, hon Chairperson. The Independent Democrats will support the ruling party for the honest programme that they are implementing and creating jobs for our people, in the poorest of the poor communities. We will also take collective responsibility to reconstruct this country because we all belong to this beautiful country of ours.
I think everybody with an open mind in this House will admit and give credit to the NCOP for bringing and taking government to the people for the first time in decades, especially since the previous regime people did not see Parliament at the local level. However, I have a question. Having said that, we all have to admit that there is a great lack of capability, and there is a great lack of experience in terms of financial management at local government level.
I think this House needs to cascade down the skills to our provinces and local government so we can enhance service delivery. The chance of the NCOP is really to become an institution of excellent service delivery; So I thought today we are going to debate a progress report tabled for us by the task team on oversight and accountability. That to me is a follow-up, but it didn’t happen. I am concerned that we need to redefine our role and function of doing oversight in the provinces.
I was very disturbed yesterday, or the day before, when we did some oversight functions in North West. At least 73 disabled people were forced together into a four-roomed house. My question to the NCOP is: What are we going to do? How are we going to remedy the situation for those sufferers?
I am convinced, and I am speaking from my heart now, that we have the resources. We can make a change in people’s lives. We just need rigorously to implement the instruments of implementation. You have to admit and agree with me also that this institution has few mechanisms to ensure accountability of people. What we need is a dedicated task team or unit, to monitor on a regular basis and go back to those people and see and check imbalances, and then say: Did we deliver to our people?
It is good and well if we go for oversight and become visible. The question, however, is: Did we manage to change the lives of those people, the sufferers, the poorest of the poor? I think that stands to reason that each and every member of this House is challenged. Forget about your political affiliation, forget about differences, but focus on the major crisis in our country currently, which is poverty.
How are we going to address this, and how are we going to bring tangible and concrete changes into those people’s lives? We will be judged by history, whether we succeeded in changing those people’s lives. We wont be free unless our people are free. Thank you. [Applause]
Mnu M MTHIMKHULU (KwaZulu-Natal): Asibonge kuMphathisihlalo. Kuyinjabulo enkulu ukuthi kule ntambama nje sizoba nale nkulumo yokuhlaziya umbiko wokuhambela kwalo Mkhandlu esifundazweni sakithi kwaZulu-Natal ngonyaka odlule.
Siyathanda ukuthi sibonge kakhulu okokuqala nje, uSihlalo ongasekho owahola ithimba lalo Mkhandlu ngempumelelo emangalisayo, kwenzeka umsebenzi nanamhlanje okusakhulunywa ngawo laphaya esifundazweni sakwaZulu-Natali. (Translation of isiZulu paragraphs follows)
[Mr M MTHIMKHULU (KwaZulu-Natal): Thank you, Chairperson. It is a great pleasure this afternoon to have an overview discussion on the report of the visit last year by this Council to the province of KwaZulu-Natal.
Firstly we would like to thank the late Chairperson, who led this House with great success, in doing a job that is still mentioned in daily discussions in KwaZulu-Natal.]
Hon Chair, it was the first time that the people of that province experienced first-hand how a democratic parliament operates. It was the first time that they experienced what was meant when it was said that the people shall govern. It became very clear that people are really governing and we have all the reasons to appreciate the step that was taken by this hon House to take this Parliament to that part of KwaZulu-Natal. Yes, as a vast province we would wish that we could have another visit to other parts of that province … [Applause.]
. . . ngoba okwenzeka ngalesiya sikhathi ukuthi abantu baba nethuba lokuthi basho izinto ezibakhathazayo. [. . . because what happened that time is that people had an opportunity to say what their problems were.]
Yes, it is a province that still has enormous challenges; for instance, it still has high levels of poverty, illiteracy and underdevelopment. But I would like to assure this House this afternoon that the new era is dawning in KwaZulu-Natal; and that, for the first time, the people of KwaZulu-Natal are experiencing peace and stability. Contrary to the recent reports alleging that there is still political violence in KwaZulu-Natal, I want to assure this Council that KwaZulu-Natal is on the path of prosperity, development and stability.
Surely, we are optimistic that those concerns that were raised by the people during the visit of this Parliament to KwaZulu-Natal will be addressed by means of our determination through our provincial government. And, the provincial growth and development strategy is now in place in our province. So, we have a reason to be optimistic that gone are the days when KwaZulu-Natal was regarded as a province of doom and uncertainty.
Chairperson, in conclusion I want to say again that we would wish that this Council would also take a decision to bring Parliament again to KwaZulu- Natal because it is a vast province, and if it would then go to other parts of the province it would help us a great deal. I thank you, Chairperson. [Applause.]
Mr J O TLHAGALE: Hon Chair of Chairs, and the hon House, the taking of Parliament to the people of KZN was received with excitement and jubilation from all quarters of that province. This gave us a sense of relief and comfort in a province previously strained by political conflicts. Our colleagues from that province were all smiles and, of course, we similarly returned the good gesture.
As the report correctly reflects, we were divided into groups headed by leaders, and we visited some schools ranging from primary to high schools in order to see for ourselves what the needs and challenges were on the ground. This is in line with the presidential decree that by the close of the year no learner should be taught under trees or in dilapidated structures.
However, the challenges and problems of KZN were no different from the challenges and problems of my province or of any other province. My party, the UCDP, is committed to supporting all genuine efforts and endeavours towards the solution of these problems and the delivery of services to our people.
Another interesting session was the open session in which people could put forth their questions in respect of any issue or concern. These were responded to by the relevant MECs and members of the respective committees. That session was very vibrant and it related to real issues and concerns that touched the lives of the people concerned.
We also visited the agricultural projects of the emerging farmers. The skills development programme of our people should be intensified in order to enable them to perform better in this line of operation. The Select Committee on Health and Social Services had presented four Bills, which were all passed at that plenary in KwaZulu-Natal. It was interesting for our people to note that passing a national Parliaments Bill is not dependent on the location at which it is passed, but on the observance of all the relevant procedural systems connected with it. In conclusion, I need to state that the UCDP supports this report. I thank you. [Applause.]
The CHIEF WHIP OF THE COUNCIL: Chairperson, Deputy Chair, the hon Chief Whip of KwaZulu-Natal, Comrade Mtholephi Mthimkhulu, and hon members in this august House; I will not leave out our special delegates from Salga. We very much appreciate your coming to this important debate. I must say that from the start, as the wheels of democracy are rolling, taking Parliament to the people starting from the Eastern Cape going north through KwaZulu-Natal, not all the people will appreciate it. There are of course those who will be making complaints on the side. Of course, it reminds me of an old Chinese saying – it is unfortunate Ms Chang is not here – that one tree falling makes much more noise than the rest of the forest growing. [Laughter.]
Those trees are growing and people are starting to reap the fruits of the trees of the struggle. And the forest will grow unstoppably so. We are very much confident that we will not be diverted from our focus. If the two special delegates, in particular, the chief whip of the whole provincial legislature of KwaZulu-Natal including the DA are saying to us they wish we come back as of yesterday, it confirms that our visit to KwaZulu-Natal was quite a success. Of course, we will not pretend about those who were engaged in other activities rather than participating proactively, because the party to which Mr Watson belongs was engaged in a marathon of caucuses, to try to wake up that tree which has fallen, and people have not even seen that one, because the people were seeing the trees of democracy.
They were seeing parliamentarians coming to them to interact with them, to listen to them, to hear their interests, to hear their needs, to take their views, to take their recommendations. They saw national Ministers; they saw MECs there. They saw parliamentarians there but they didn’t see you because you were engaged in this marathon of caucuses. And you missed the point that people were making.
I want to say Mrs Ngcobo that we very much appreciate your words of encouragement because you spoke as a politician rather than a person coming from a particular party to say you wish that our visit could have been extended to other areas. Of course, due to logistical constraints we could not, but we also wished to do so. One member of the House is so much concerned about the financial constraints. We do, however, wish that we could make these visits every fortnight to be there with the people.
But I must say that we had very constructive inputs and debates from all parties in this House - except one. If you listen to Rev Adolph, even he has made a very constructive input into this debate. The same went for the hon Adams.
But let me preface my prepared speech by . . . I was still speaking about the KwaZulu-Natal visit but I have never gone beyond that. While I am still speaking about the KwaZulu-Natal visit let me quote the Freedom Charter where it says:
We the people of South Africa declare for all our country and the world to know that only a democratic state based on the will of all the people can secure to all their birth right without distinction of colour, race, sex or belief.
It further goes on to a say that the people shall govern and all people shall be entitled to take part in the administration of the country.
That is what we are doing with this programme of taking Parliament to the people. That was further confirmed by the President on 5 November - and I quote him where he says:
I would like to congratulate the NCOP for taking their sittings to the various provinces thus taking government to the people and opening space for our provinces to interact with their public representatives. This is important because these interactions do ensure that we are better able together to address the many pressing challenges that confront our people.
If you analyse this statement as made by a mature politician you will understand that we do appreciate that there are still challenges facing our people. That’s why also the President further spoke at length in terms of our role as the NCOP, the oversight that we need to play in terms of the last or the third sphere. Let me say the “third sphere,” because it is not the last. It is equally as important as the other two spheres of local government and mention was made of Project Consolidate which amongst other things aims to focus on the following areas: one, to ensure community development that would empower communities and encourage the participation of our people in the spirit of Letsema and Vuk’uzenzele; secondly to ensure that we implement the integrated human settlement approach that was announced by the Minister of Housing; thirdly, the implementation of free basic services to poor households ensuring that there are proper and appropriate billing systems and working for the reduction of municipal debt; and last, to mention among the many which are there, the setting of systems and mechanisms that will root out corruption.
We should also appreciate the fact that there was a survey conducted by the Department of Provincial and Local Government and in that report it says 241 municipalities have more than 30% of those households who have some form of an income, earning less than R1 600 per month. That also reflects the capacity in terms of revenue generation that those local municipalities can collect, which also poses challenges, because the input also dictates the output of those municipalities.
It does not need anyone to go to the university of Sussex to understand the point we are stressing. There is a whole range of things, if you have carefully listened to the speech of the President. But the other one say 226 municipalities have more than 50% of indigent households. If you have grown up in poverty-stricken communities you will understand what that means to that particular local municipality in terms of the challenges which it is facing. However there are those who have the slogan: What is bad for South Africa is good for us. But what we are saying is that those challenges which are there need all of us to take them head-on so as to have them as our collective responsibility to assist one another; and we must spare neither courage nor strength to see to it that everyone gets a better life for all. Thank you, Chair. [Applause.]
Debate concluded.
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: That concludes the debate. I shall now put the question, and the question is that the report be adopted. As the decision is dealt with in terms of section 65 of the Constitution I shall first ascertain whether all the delegation heads are present in the chamber to cast their province’s vote. Are all delegations present?
In accordance with Rule 71 I shall first allow provinces an opportunity to make their declaration of vote if they so wish. We shall now proceed to the voting on the question. I shall do this in alphabetical order per province. The delegation heads must please indicate to the Chair whether they vote in favour, against or abstain from voting.
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: Eastern Cape?
Mrs B N DLULANE: I-Eastern Cape iyayamkela. [Eastern Cape supports.]
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: Free State?
Mr T S SETONA: In favour.
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: Gauteng?
Mr E M SOGONI: Siyaxhasa. [We support.]
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: KwaZulu-Natal?
Mr M MTHIMKHULU: KwaZulu-Natal votes in favour.
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: Limpopo?
Mrs H F MATLANYANE: Limpopo votes in favour.
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: Mpumalanga?
Ms M P THEMBA: Mpumalanga iyayemukela. [Mpumalanga supports.]
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: Northern Cape?
Mr K SINCLAIR: Northern Cape supports.
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: North West?
Mr Z S KOLWENI: North West ke a rona. [North West supports.]
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: Western Cape?
Mr F ADAMS: Steun. [Supports.]
The CHAIRPERSON OF COMMITTEES: All nine provinces have voted in favour, therefore I declare the report adopted.
Report accordingly adopted in accordance with section 65 of the Constitution.
. . . nale Ndlu, ngiyafisa ukuthi ngokombiko waKwaZulu-Natali ngisho ukuthi amakomidi aye ahlangana ase ebheka ukuthi yini ebhekelene nekomidini ngalinye. Ngikhuluma nje ngesonto likamhlaka-28 kuya kumhlaka-4 kunamakomidi azoyobheka KwaZulu-Natali ukuthi ngabe ikhona yini inqubekela phambili emveni kokuba uMkhandlu kaZwelonke weziFundazwe kade iKwaZulu- Natali. (Translation of isiZulu paragraph follows.)
[. . . and this House, in terms of the report from KwaZulu-Natal, wishes to report that the committees came together to determine the duties of each committee. As I am speaking, during the week of the 28th to the 4th, there are committees that are going to KwaZulu-Natal to establish whether any progress has been made since the visit by the National Council of Provinces.]
And therefore I want to assure you, Chairperson, that as committees we are making sure that we do follow-ups on whatever activities we have done.
Ngalawo mazwi sekuphelile ebesikudingida ngakhio indlu iyaguqa. [That concludes the business of the day. The House is adjourned.] The Council adjourned at 16:26. ____
ANNOUNCEMENTS, TABLINGS AND COMMITTEE REPORTS
TUESDAY, 25 JANUARY 2005
ANNOUNCEMENTS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- Assent by President in respect of Bills
(1) Public Investment Corporation Bill [B 6B - 2004] - Act No 23 of
2004 (assented to and signed by President on 11 December 2004);
(2) Dental Technicians Amendment Bill [B 63 - 2003] - Act No 24 of
2004 (assented to and signed by President on 25 November 2004);
(3) Public Audit Bill [B 1 - 2004] - Act No 25 of 2004 (assented to
and signed by President on 14 December 2004);
(4) Adjustments Appropriation Bill [B 21 - 2004] - Act No 27 of 2004
(assented to and signed by President on 1 December 2004);
(5) Petroleum Pipelines Levies Bill [B 18 - 2004] - Act No 28 of
2004 (assented to and signed by President on 14 December 2004);
and
(6) National Small Business Amendment Bill [B 23B - 2004] - Act No
29 of 2004 (assented to and signed by President on 11 December
2004).
- Introduction of Bills
(1) The Minister of Minerals and Energy
(i) Minerals and Energy Laws Amendment Bill [B 1 - 2005]
(National Assembly - sec 75) [Explanatory summary of Bill and
prior notice of its introduction published in Government
Gazette No 26778 of 17 September 2004.]
Introduction and referral to the Portfolio Committee on Minerals
and Energy of the National Assembly, as well as referral to the
Joint Tagging Mechanism (JTM) for classification in terms of Joint
Rule 160, on 18 January 2005.
In terms of Joint Rule 154 written views on the classification of
the Bill may be submitted to the Joint Tagging Mechanism (JTM)
within three parliamentary working days.
TABLINGS
National Council of Provinces
- The Chairperson
Report of the visit of the National Council of Provinces to Empangeni,
KwaZulu-Natal, 1-5 November 2004:
Executive Summary
During 1-5 November 2004, the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) had a sitting in the KwaZulu-Natal Province. This initiative was part of a strategic inclusive process of involving communities within the Taking Parliament to the People project. The sitting also encompassed the NCOP’s Vision 2009 Strategy, which seeks to expand the Council’s oversight activities over the next five years.
The Council undertook various meetings and site visits with the communities in the greater Empangeni area. Various recommendations were made during the course of the meetings and site visits to strengthen the role of the NCOP, Government departments and key role-players to effect and enhance service delivery.
• During the session on co-operative governance and issues of poverty,
rural development and health it was emphasised that the interaction
between Members of the Provincial Legislature, Members of the National
Council of Provinces and National Ministers would boost the quality of
legislation and enhance effective parliamentary oversight at all
levels of government. The insight of National Ministers regarding
issues with which the province is grappling would be further enhanced.
Statistical information on socio-economic conditions in the Province
was presented to underline the urgency of the need to counteract
underdevelopment. It was noted that extreme levels of poverty are
being exported to informal settlements as people try to escape the
unpleasant conditions in the rural areas. Such movement to rural areas
then creates the new problem of unplanned urban resettlement. Any
effort at correcting these problems will only succeed when combined
with integrated rural sustainable development.
• The visits to schools constituted part of an initiative to ensure that
no learner will be educated under a tree. A document on the current
conditions at all schools in KwaZulu-Natal has been prepared and this
estimates that a total of approximately 6 000 schools are in poor
condition. The majority of these schools (90%) are in rural areas, and
the Department of Public Works will be responsible for the
construction of additional classroom facilities. Other challenges that
emerged during the course of the site visits include: the drop-out
rate of learners can be ascribed to poor facilities and the financial
position of parents, many schools have no ablution facilities or
running water, many schools do not have sufficient classrooms and high
levels of poverty result in alcohol abuse and teenage pregnancies.
• The NCOP meeting with local women focused on the structures and
institutions set up by Government over the course of the past 10 years
to improve the quality of women’s lives. The presentations touched on
the legislation introduced to give effect to gender equity and some of
the Government initiatives to enhance women’s lives. Some of the key
challenges that still obstruct the political, social and economic
empowerment of women were highlighted and some potential solutions to
some of these were discussed.
• The site visits to the cane and citrus farm and women’s co-operative
and the meeting held with farmers served to highlight several critical
issues. Problems such as inadequate market access to emerging cane
growers, the inadequate infrastructure to move merchandise to and from
the cane fields, inadequate training and capacity-building initiatives
and high levels of unemployment which often exacerbate the crime
levels were discussed in some detail. Despite these challenges, many
of the participants cited some levels of success in creating jobs
through their commercial ventures.
• The public hearing on the Expanded Public Works Programme and
sustainable subsistence farming highlighted the manner in which the
programme will create jobs, develop skills and alleviate poverty.
Through the creation of opportunities using labour intensive methods,
significant numbers of unemployed people will be drawn into productive
work and gain skills, thereby increasing their capacity to earn an
income. To date, it has been reported that 38 000 work opportunities
have been created between April and June 2004, since the launch of the
EPWP. Concerns were raised about the manner in which people are
employed on these projects as well as the difficulties in accessing
funding for projects and securing tenders.
• The public hearing on poverty alleviation and educational and social
needs pointed out that the most important focus of government
programmes was the reduction of poverty in conjunction with ensuring
greater access to health and other social services. Presentations
focused on the poverty alleviation projects implemented by the
different departments, as well as those programmes meant to address
not only income poverty, but also quality of life more generally. The
focus is also developmental in nature, and acknowledges that people
must be able to contribute to the development of their own lives. Very
little reference was made with regard to educational needs in the
context of poverty.
• The meeting with the youth and people with disabilities focused on the
mandate and challenges faced by the National Youth Commission, the
mandate and challenges of the Umsobomvu Youth Fund, initiatives in the
Presidency to deal with youth-related issues and the mandate and
challenges faced by the Disabled People South Africa.
• The meeting with councillors on local government matters reinforced
the fact that the most significant way in which the NCOP can respond
to the challenges faced by local government is by strengthening its
oversight work. Through its oversight work the NCOP plays a critical
role in ensuring that provincial and national government continues to
provide the institutional support to local government that it needs to
discharge the constitutional obligations it is entrusted with. This
includes making sure that municipalities have the capacity to
implement social and economic development programmes such as the
Expanded Public Works Programme to help government achieve its
objective of halving unemployment and poverty by 2014. The Department
of Provincial and Local Government (DPLG) has recognised that none of
the role players in this sector can adequately deal with all the
challenges facing municipalities on their own. In recognition of this,
DPLG has embarked on Project Consolidate, a targeted hands-on
engagement programme to deal with problems facing local government.
Through this initiative, municipalities that require the greatest
support have been profiled. The intention is to mobilise national and
provincial government, state-owned enterprises and the private sector
to support local government.
- Introduction
This report reflects the key issues that emerged during the course of the visit of the National Council of Provinces (NCOP) to KwaZulu-Natal during 1- 5 November 2004. This visit constituted part of a broader initiative to “Take Parliament to the People” and to engage in parliamentary oversight initiatives. This report is therefore constituted of several subreports of each of the various meetings that took place during the course of the oversight visit. It is structured as follows:
• Session on co-operative governance and issues of poverty, rural
development and health (1 November 2004).
• Visit to the Macekane Primary and Bhekulwazi High Schools (1 November
2004).
• Visit to the Thanduyise High School, the Amangwe Primary School and
the Dover Combined School (1 November 2004).
• Meeting with women (1 November 2004).
• Visit to Thathunyawo Cane and Citrus Farm and the Phezukomkhono
Women’s Co-operative (2 November 2004).
• Meeting with farmers (2 November 2004).
• Public hearing on the Expanded Public Works Programme and sustainable
subsistence farming (2 November).
• Public hearing on poverty alleviation and educational and social needs
• (3 November 2004).
• Meeting with youth and people with disabilities (3 November 2004).
• Meeting with councillors on local government matters (4 November
2004).
- Visits to schools
2.1 The rationale for visiting schools
• The visits to schools stem from the NCOP’s “Taking Parliament to
the People” initiative and the President’s commitment that by 2005,
no learner will be educated under a tree.
• The MEC for Education in KwaZulu-Natal indicated that the
department had prepared a comprehensive document on the current
conditions at all schools in the province – in total approximately
6 000, most of which were in a bad condition.
• The majority of these schools (90%) are in rural areas, and the
Department of Public Works is responsible for the construction of
additional classroom facilities.
2.2 Visit to the Macekane Primary School and the Bhekulwazi High School
The visit to the schools took place on 1 November 2004 and the delegation was headed by the Honourable Ms JL Kgoali and included the KwaZulu-Natal MEC for Education as well as Members of the KwaZulu-Natal Provincial legislature and Local Government Councillors.
2.2.1 A profile of Macekane Primary School
• Macekane Primary was constructed in 1964.
• In the past two years, Macekane Primary’s pass rate was 68%.
• The educators are committed to improving (a) the attendance rate
and (b) the pass rate.
• The school employs 15 educators and has 105 learners.
• Twelve out of the existing 16 classrooms can be utilised (the rest
of the classrooms are damaged).
• The classrooms do not have ceilings, blackboards cannot be used and
four to five learners have to share two-seater desks.
• An attempt to lead water from the TICOR South Africa Plants was
unsuccessful.
• Although a feeding scheme is in operation, the storage and cooking
areas are totally dysfunctional.
2.2.2 A profile of the Bhekulwazi High School
• The school has 16 educators and 389 learners, six classrooms and a
hall divided into two.
• Bhekulwazi High can accommodate 250 learners, and at least a
further eight classrooms have to be provided.
• In the absence of sufficient classroom accommodation, some learners
have to be taught under trees, and during the rainy season there
are no classes.
• Water supply is erratic, although the school does have a standpipe
for water.
• Bhekulwazi paid Uthungulu for labour and 800 meters of pipe, but
the tap is not yet in working condition.
• The chemicals for teaching physics are stored in a small office,
which is (a) a fire hazard and (b) potentially toxic.
2.2.3 Challenges
• The drop-out rate, which is ascribed to poor facilities and the
financial position of parents.
• No ablution facilities or running water.
• Lack of sufficient classrooms.
• High poverty levels which often result in alcohol abuse and teenage
pregnancies.
• Insufficient educational equipment.
2.3 Visit to Tholokuhle High School and Sibonokuhle High School
Mr M J Mahlangu, Deputy Chairperson of the NCOP, led this delegation, of which Mr W Mchunu, Speaker of the KwaZulu-Natal Legislature also formed part, along with other members of the NCOP, MPLs and Councillors.
2.3.1 A profile of Tholokuhle High School
• Tholokuhle High School has 1 400 learners and 46 educators. The
school has a full management team consisting of the Headmaster;
five Heads of Department, and eight Natural Science educators.
• The school offers three educational streams. It also has a
Hospitality Centre whose Grade 12 learners wrote exams for the
first time this year.
• Tholokuhle High School has entered into agreements with the
Universities of Zululand and Pretoria, who send subject specialists
to teach learners from Grade 10 upwards.
• The school receives financial support from various businesses,
including Telkom, Casme, Mondi, and the Zululand Chamber of
Business.
2.3.2 Challenges
• The school experiences a shortage of educators, especially in
relation to Mathematics and Science.
• There is no transport for learners to and from the school.
• The school has no hall, tuck shop or conference rooms.
• There is no funding for Internet services.
2.3.3 A profile of Sibonokuhle High School
• The school has 682 learners, 24 educators and 18 classrooms, one of
which is used as a staffroom. The administration building was burnt
down during the violence in 1989.
• The water supply to the school is erratic, as the standpipe only
works in the mornings. However, a new pipe is expected to be
installed from Enseleni.
• The school does not have electricity in all classrooms, and the
schools grounds have been fenced in in such a manner that it leaves
little space for extracurricular activities or sport.
2.3.4 Challenges
• The school would like more relevant educators for the new
curriculum. One educator has been appointed for Computer Studies,
but there are no computers or any other form of Information
Technology.
• Another educator has been appointed to teach Technical Drawing, but
there are no facilities.
• The area has a high unemployment rate, with the result that up to
40% of learners cannot afford the school fees.
• Grade 9 is being taught Science with no equipment or laboratory,
and there is no space to set up a laboratory.
• The pass rate of the school is declining, and few learners are
reaching Grade 12 as they cannot reach the promotion requirements.
2.4 Visit to the Thanduyise High School, Amangwe Primary School and the Dover Combined School
The delegation was headed by Honourable Mr V V Z Windvoël. It included Members of the KwaZulu-Natal Provincial legislature and Members of the NCOP.
2.4.1 A profile of Thanduyise High School
• The school has a learner population of 823 with 24 educators, which
translates into a ratio of one educator per 46 learners.
• Thanduyise is a fairly-resourced school compared to some of the
schools that were visited by the delegation. It has a well-kept
library, a science laboratory and a biology laboratory including a
computer laboratory with 30 computers that were donated by Eskom.
However, the school has inadequate sportsfields for learners.
• In the 2003 matric results the school achieved a 92% pass rate, which
has been the norm at the school for the past years.
2.4.2 Challenges
The school faces the following challenges:
• A shortage of teachers.
• A shortage of reading material.
• Lack of communication between teachers and the district within which
the school falls.
• The abolition of corporal punishment makes it difficult for teachers
to instil discipline among learners.
2.4.3 A profile of Amangwe Primary School
• The school starts from Grade 8 to Grade 12.
• It has a learner population of 254 with 14 educators.
• The majority of learners come from the immediate vicinity of the
school, which is a semirural area.
• The school has no electricity; ceilings and doors are broken due to
vandalism.
2.4.5 Challenges
The school faces the following challenges:
• Lack of ablution facilities.
• Shortage of water facilities.
• Shortage of qualified teachers, in particular science teachers.
2.4.6 A profile of Dover Combined Farm School
• The school starts from Grade 1 to Grade 12, with a learner population
of 792 and 22 educators.
• The school is one of the best performing rural schools in the country,
for the past years it has been achieving a 100% pass rate. This has
earned the school several awards.
• The school was originally owned by a farmer and has since been
transferred to the Department of Education. Most of the funding for
the school is sourced from the private sector.
• The school has embarked on a programme of twinning with other schools
from the United States of America and Europe. During the visit by the
delegation one of the learners had just arrived from an exchange
programme with France.
2.4.7 Outcomes
• The provincial Department of Education is entering into public
agreements with service providers in an attempt to provide
additional support.
• Since there is currently a backlog of 16 500 classrooms, the
provincial Department of Education will prioritise the provision of
classrooms.
• In the next financial year, an allocation had been made to ensure
that four classrooms, one science laboratory and one media centre
is constructed at Bhekulwazi High School.
• The provincial Education Department is committed to meet the
commitment by the President that by next year no learners will be
learning under trees.
• Contractors for constructing the additional classrooms would be
appointed within the next 14 days.
2.5 Visit to KwaNandi Primary School and Bhekeshowe High School
Mr T Setona, Deputy Chairperson of Committees in the NCOP led this delegation of Members of the NCOP, the Provincial Legislature and Councillors.
2.5.1 Profile of KwaNandi Primary School
• The school has 383 learners and 11 educators plus one paid for by
an unnamed NGO with a teacher/learner ratio of 1: 40/45. The school
has 19 classrooms, some of which are used as administration rooms.
The grades range from Grade R to Grade 7.
• The annual school fee is R30,00 but 50% of school fees is still
outstanding.
• The school was established in 1957 but the building is still in a
satisfactory condition because the district municipality has
renovated it. It is properly fenced with razor wire.
• There is only one office, which is used by the principal. There is
no administration block and this causes classroom congestion
because some of the classrooms are used as admin rooms. One
classroom is used as a computer room.
• There are toilets but they are not working because there is no
water and because of the soil type there are problems with
drainage. There is also no water and the school depends on the
tanks and a borehole and both these resources dry up more often.
• The school was provided with electricity in August after ten years
of requests.
2.5.2 Challenges
• There is a high crime rate in the area of the school, and the car
of one of the staff members was hijacked in front of the school
gates. There were also incidents of breaking into the classrooms
before the school was fenced with the razor wire.
• There is a problem with transport because the school is in a rural
area. The learners and even the teachers have to travel long
distances. The roads to the school are inaccessible.
• The school has received 20 computers, which is not enough to serve
even one class. There is no computer room and one of the classrooms
is used as a computer room. The school has no resources for sport,
recreation or Grade R facilities
2.5.3 Profile of Bhekeshowe High School
• The school has a population of 600 learners and 17 educators, which
translates to a ratio of about 40 learners per educator.
• The school fees are R90 per annum and the parents are trying their
best to pay with a default rate of 20%.
• There are 21 classrooms with only two electrified and none have
ceilings. The roofs on one block were torn off by the storm. There
is no proper fencing at the school and this results in the school
being easily vandalised.
• The matric pass rate is gradually improving at the school. In 2000
it was 24%; 2001, 43%; 2002, 53%; and in 2003, 80%. There are
several strategies aimed at improving results and the Department
implements them yearly.
• The learners are educated from time to time on HIV/AIDS. Last month
Grades 7 and 8 were addressed and on 2 November 2004 somebody from
a local NGO will address them on health issues.
2.5.4 Challenges
• Because of the rural nature of the school, the curriculum does not
address the local needs in its subjects. The school therefore wants
to introduce Agricultural Science and Computer Studies. However,
the school is struggling to obtain computers because there is no
security for them.
• The bad roads in this rural area make the school inaccessible to
the learners and educators especially during rainy days.
• The school is struggling to obtain resources, human and otherwise.
There is a shortage of educators. There is one laboratory, which is
poorly equipped. No playgrounds for learners.
• The school depends on tanks for water. A tap was put up early in
2004, but it dries up regularly.
• There is no security at the school. The school has hired two
security guards at R400 per month paid for by the community. The
guards are sometimes attacked, as they have nothing to defend
themselves with.
• The school used to have ABET but classes are no longer offered due
to problems in handling both ABET and full-time learners.
• There are no computers; learners have to go to Empangeni and pay R6
000 for basic computer courses after matric.
• There is a high pregnancy rate in the school and this year has been
the worst when compared to others.
2.6 Visit to Ndesheni School and isikhala seNkosi High School
Mrs M Oliphant, Chairperson of Committees, led the delegation. The delegation comprised member of the NCOP, MPLs and Councillors.
2.6.1 Profile of Ndesheni School
• The grades at Ndesheni range from grade 8 to grade 12. There are 21
educators and 521 learners. The ratio is one educator to 38
learners – 1:38.
• The performance of the school in terms of matric results is very
good. The pass rate has been 73% in the past 3 years.
• The school falls within the jurisdiction of the Mthunzini district,
and within the traditional authority of iNkosi Dube.
• School fees are R120 per annum. The area is a poor area resulting
in most parents being unable to afford to pay. There is a 60%
default rate.
• Classrooms are not in a good condition, and there is a shortage of
classrooms. One block (six classrooms) was burnt down completely,
and has not been renovated. One classroom is being used as an
administration office. Some of the classrooms have ceilings, but
most do not. There are lights in one block, but not in the others.
The floors are passable in one block, but not in others. There is a
shortage of furniture for both the classrooms and the
administration office. There is no laboratory and no library. There
is no assembly hall.
• There are 12 standpipes, with uninterrupted water supplied by the
Municipality. However, there are no toilets for learners. There are
two structures put up with no roof, used by both girls and boys.
These are not in a usable condition. There are two toilets used by
teachers, also in a bad condition.
• There are no sport facilities or equipment. The school used to play
soccer and netball but cannot manage now.
• Books and computers were donated by RBCT, but since the fire, they
were not replaced by the company as there is no security.
• There is a high rate of teenage pregnancy (almost 30%), which is
solved by allowing pregnant girls to attend school until close to
delivery, and then giving them home teaching for 3 months. This
year there were 20 pregnant learners. There are also HIV and AIDS
programmes in place to assist affected learners. One dedicated
educator is responsible for the programme.
• There is no school bus; learners have to travel long distances.
They therefore use the public transport.
2.6.3 Challenges
• The school is situated in a poor area, with an estimated 15% of
learners showing signs of HIV infection. Most learners have lost
one or both of their parents.
• The school is not properly fenced, and has no security guard.
• The school is in need of electricity, additional classrooms, a
laboratory and library, learning materials and proper toilets.
• There are no computers. The use of computers will assist to set up
proper administration. Currently boxes are used to store important
documents of the school.
2.6.4 Profile of Isikhala seNkosi High School
• The school currently has eight teachers (excluding the principal
and a Zulu teacher who resigned in September). The position of the
principal has been in dispute since 2003, as learners dissatisfied
with his management style had chased him away from the school. The
principal is now stationed at Dlangezwa High School.
• The grades range from grade 8 to grade 12. There are eight
educators and 319 learners. The ratio is one educator to 38
learners – 1: 38. In terms of matric results, the school had been
performing well from 1999 to 2002. The performance was as follows
in 1999 – 27%; 2000 – 37%; and 2002 – 74%. This was indicating an
increase in the pass rate. In 2003 the pass rate was 42%. The
delegation heard that the cause for the decline in pass rate was
attributed to disturbances at the school and lack of learner
commitment to school.
• There are eight classrooms (prefabricated building donated by RBM);
two are used as an administration block. Classrooms are in a good
condition (freshly painted) with burglar-barred doors; no broken
windows were visible; however, the school does not have
electricity. A significant number of desks are broken and need to
be replaced as a matter of urgency. The school also has no
laboratory.
• There is one water tap that is operational, while there are two
toilets for teachers and five for learners (two for girls and three
for boys).
• There is a bus that drops off learners at school and picks them up
after school.
2.6.5 Challenges
• The issue of the school principal needs to be resolved as a matter
of urgency.
• There is a high rate of teen pregnancy. In addition, there is no
dedicated educator responsible for HIV/AIDS programmes. Instead,
social workers visit the school on a regular basis.
• School stationery/material is not received on time.
- Opening Ceremony: Session on Co-operative Governance and Issues of Poverty, Rural Development and Health
The meeting on co-operative governance took place on 1 November 2004. The week provided an opportunity for the principles of cooperative governance, as enshrined in the Constitution, to be effected to the fullest possible extent, to practically enrich the co-operative interaction between the various spheres of government. The meeting was addressed by the following speakers: Hon Mr Sibusiso Ndebele, Premier of Kwazulu-Natal; His Majesty, King Goodwill Zwelithini KaBhekizulu; the Hon Speaker of the KwaZulu-Natal Legislature, Mr W Mchunu; Hon Councillor, BV Mthetwa; Executive Mayor of the uThungulu District; followed by concluding remarks by the Hon Chairperson of the NCOP, JL Kgoali.
The following issues were raised in the session:
3.1 Co-operative governance
• The interaction between Members of the Provincial Legislature,
Members of the National Council of Provinces and National Ministers
would boost the quality of legislation and enhance effective
parliamentary oversight at all levels of government. The insight of
National Ministers regarding issues with which the province is
grappling would be further enhanced.
3.2 Poverty and Rural development
The Premier of Kwazulu Natal provided statistical information on
the Province, which underlined the need to counteract
underdevelopment. Out of a total population of 9,5 million, 2,1
million cannot read or write, and 56% of the population is under
the age of 24 years. Over 4 000 schools do not have electricity,
while 36% do not have toilets. Out of 51 municipal local
governments, 31 are unable to provide services.
• The importance of supporting a better quality of life in the rural
areas was emphasised. Successful rural development will be the
first step of the Government towards the eradication of slums and
informal settlements in the peri-urban centres. It will assist with
the reduction of unemployment and starvation.
• It was noted that extreme levels of poverty are being exported to informal settlements as people try to escape the unpleasant conditions in the rural areas. Such movement to urban areas creates a new problem of unplanned urban resettlement. Any effort at correcting these problems will only succeed when combined with integrated rural sustainable development.
• The youth need to have access to amenities that will enhance their social development into healthy adults with a morally upright attitude to life. It is important to create an environment that would encourage the youth to have positive aspirations with regard to their future. It was cautioned that, if not given attention and guidance, young people will slide into degenerate forms of behaviour, including drug abuse, crime, early, unplanned pregnancies and all associated social and health complications.
3.3 Health and related issues
• The Province faces a number of health challenges. The lack of
accessible, safe potable water led to an outbreak of cholera that
affected thousands of people in KwaZulu-Natal. It was stressed that
Government must ensure that the scourge of HIV and AIDS,
Tuberculosis and other diseases is eliminated.
• With regard to solid waste management, a waste management site has
been built in Empangeni at the cost of approximately R21 million.
During the first year the performance of this facility started to
show that the Government’s expectations had been met and would even
be exceeded.
• A need was expressed for communities to be economically empowered
so that they are able to pay for the provision of services.
• While administrative centres in the rural areas play a vital role
in providing government services, traditional leaders have a role
to play in the delivery of services and in providing access to
clean water and information.
- Meeting with Women
The meeting with women took place on 1 November 2004 at Empangeni. It was addressed by the Hon Ms JL Kgoali (Chairperson of the NCOP), Ms V Ngqasa (Isintu Foods), Dr E Kornegay (the Presidency), Ms N Ndaba (National Association for Women’s Empowerment), Ms N Legoabe (GCIS Chief Director: Provincial and Local Liaison) and Ms M Matiwane (Department of Trade and Industry).
4.1 Legislation
• Over the course of the past 10 years, Parliament has introduced
progressive legislation to improve the lives of women. Key
legislation to impact on women’s lives includes the Maintenance
Act, the Domestic Violence Act, the Recognition of Customary
Marriages Act and the Welfare Laws Amendment Act. Parliament wants
all people to benefit from the legislation that has been passed and
wants to ensure that people know how to use the legislation. It is
important that women, especially women in the rural areas, are
informed about this legislation.
• Ms J Piliso-Seroke of the Commission for Gender Equality emphasised
that the Constitution ensures that everyone is equal and the law
therefore strives to protect women’s rights.
• The importance of the Criminal Procedure Act was emphasised. The
Act assists courts in their decisions to refuse bail in rape cases
where weapons have been used or where gang rape has taken place.
The Criminal Law Amendment Act has also benefited women as illegal
evictions can now be prevented in terms of the law.
4.2 Government Policies
• Government intends to mainstream gender into all its policies. It
is the responsibility of the Office on the Status of Women to
ensure that gender issues are integrated into all Government
policies and to monitor whether what the Government has promised to
deliver has actually reached women in all communities.
• Various policies have been put in place by Government, eg social
policies, health policies, etc, to improve the conditions under
which women live.
4.3 Budgeting for Women’s Needs
These are areas where the Government has budgeted specifically to benefit women. Parliament believes that it is important to engage with the people on the ground about these matters to make sure that the money is being spent on the people it is intended for.
4.4 Government Programmes
• It is important that women are informed of the Government
programmes that are in place in order to take full advantage of the
opportunities that are available to them.
• The programmes of Government are not only aimed at women, but also
at men. However, it is essential that Government services reach
women.
• The Government has put in place several Entrepreneurial Business
Support Programmes and has been the main catalyst for ensuring that
women receive the necessary support for their businesses.
The following programmes have been put in place:
A. Initiatives of the Department of Trade and Industry (DTI)
Programme: Technology for Women in Business
• This programme is aimed at encouraging women to access and use
technology to increase and strengthen their enterprises.
• The programme awards those who succeed and presents them as role
models.
• The programme offers training opportunities, eg the DTI has
established partnerships with information technology companies to
provide training.
• The Techno-Girl programme targets girls and encourages them to
pursue careers in the field of science and technology.
Programme: South African Women Entrepreneurs Network (SAWEN)[1]
• The SAWEN programme was launched nationally in 2002. Provincial
branches were subsequently launched in 2003 and 2004.
• The network provides a vehicle for women entrepreneurs to act as a
single voice.
• It provides support through information sharing, training and
business advice.
• The structure is an independent organisation that is driven by
women and has a close partnership with DTI.
Programme: Access to Finance for Women in Business
• The DTI is working towards the launch of the APEX fund in December
2004, which will focus on financing for micro women-owned
enterprises. The APEX fund will be targeted primarily at the second
economy and will grant microloans from R20 to R 10 000.
• The DTI has put in place business incentives such as the Black
Business Supplier Development Programme (BBSDP), and the Small and
Medium Enterprise Development Programme (SMEDP), which are
available to women in business. The BBSDP subsidises the costs of
technical support and consultant advice to companies so that they
are able to upgrade their capabilities. The SMEDP gives business a
cash rebate on their investments in order to promote the growth of
enterprises.
• The DTI caters for broad-based empowerment initiatives that
specifically target rural communities. They have products that
support start-up enterprises through Kula-Start, which primarily
targets rural women.
• The DTI has identified problems pertaining to access to finance
that face women in business and will look at new initiatives to
address these constraints.
B. Initiatives of the Department of Minerals and Energy
• The Mining Charter sets a target of 10% women employees within five
years.
• Other aspects of the Charter where the quota is applicable are:
procurement, beneficiation, community development, housing and
nutrition and employment equity.
• BP and Caltex currently have women as shareholders. Similar
opportunities with other companies are in the process of being
negotiated.
• Business structures for women have been established such as the
South African Women in Mining (SAWIMA) and Women In Oil, Gas and
Energy (WOESA).
C. Initiatives of the Department of Agriculture
• The Department of Agriculture administers the Women Farmer of the
Year awards, which recognises women who succeed in exporting their
products regionally and internationally.
• Through the Land Reform for Agriculture Programme (LRAD),
development finance has been made available for accessing land in
the price range of R 20 000 to R 100 000, based on the size of the
enterprise and ownership status.
• Support is provided to research seed models required for both local
and international markets as part of an initiative to help women
start nurseries.
• Marketing agencies assist in linking women farmers and clients.
• Through Agri-Industry Training, women are being assisted to improve
the quality of their products.
D. Initiatives of the Department of Science and Technology
• The focus of the Department is on profiling and promoting women in
the sector.
• Minister’s Awards are held to award the top 100 companies in
engineering, science and technology.
• Women are encouraged to enter the sector.
E. Initiatives of the Department of Communications
• The Department encourages women to enter the Information and
Communications and Telecommunications (ICT) sector.
• The Department provides support to women entering the field through
mentorship by company directors.
• The Khulisa Scheme has been established, which provides mentorship
and training to women.
• The Department has established telecentres and ensures that some
are owned by women to provide easy access to ICT.
F. Initiatives of the Department of Housing
• The Department of Housing supports the entry of women into the
housing construction arena.
• The Department supports a Women for Housing project that assists
women building contractors through the provision of training, helps
to place women in construction firms and encourages women to pursue
housing-related careers.
• The Department has set targets for women being awarded at least 10%
of housing construction contracts. This has, however, not been met.
G. Initiatives of the Department of Public Works
The Department has set targets for women’s participation in the
construction sector as part of the Construction Industry
Development Programme.
• The Department supports women enterprises through its Targeted
Procurement Policy (TPP) and the Emerging Contractor Development
Programme (ECDP). The TPP and ECDP supports the Women in
Construction Programme, which ensures that women-owned and managed
construction companies receive contracts and women are
beneficiaries of all support initiatives.
• Women are supported through training, the provision of general
business skills, tendering and procurement skills and specialist
training in areas such as electricity and plumbing.
• The Department manages a database of women in construction.
4.5 Multi-Purpose Community Centres
• The Multi-Purpose Community Centre (MPCC) Programme strives to
create a people’s contract for more efficient, people-centered and
developmental government.
MPCCs are a vehicle for ensuring that Government can deliver
services in an accessible manner to poor communities. MPCCs aim to
address historical socio-economic issues whereby some citizens were
deprived of access to government information and services.
• The MPCC Programme started in 1999, with the aim of establishing a
centre in each of the district municipalities by December 2004.
There are currently 63 MPCCs in the country. Six of these are in
KwaZulu-Natal, namely, Bamshela, Mbazwana, Tugela Ferry, Dukuza,
Mbabazane and Dududu. Plans are at an advanced stage to establish a
centre in Nkandla. Through the MPCCs, communities can access more
than 500 services. By 2014 the Government plans to establish an
MPCC in each local municipality.
• MPCCs are places where a number of services are provided by local,
provincial and national government as well as parastatals, NGOs,
CBOs and the private sector. The services offered at an MPCC are
those that have been identified by the community.
• Government is making special efforts to make services accessible to
every citizen close to where they live. In addition to the MPCCs,
Community Development Workers have been appointed and the Batho
Pele e-Gateway, which uses internet and computers to bring
information to communities, has been set up. Imbizos are also an
important part of bringing government and people together in
working for a better life for all.
• Communities need to work in partnership with the government at
national, provincial and local levels to facilitate the process of
community development.
4.6 Challenges
Participants at the meeting identified the following challenges:
• Notwithstanding the huge strides made by the government in the
advancement of women in all sectors, there are still areas that
need to be addressed. These areas include facilitating access to
some government structures and institutions, the implementation of
government policies, and the relaxation of requirements for
individuals to qualify for loans or government grants.
• Before the current dispensation, women were victims of extreme
poverty as a result of a lack of resources and skills. Rural women
have been particularly vulnerable.
• Government should arrange that officials visit rural areas to
ascertain what is required, as people in rural areas do not know
about the many structures that exist to assist those in farm areas.
• Women at grassroots level, particularly rural women, are engaged in
small business endeavours, but lack information and support on
business and marketing strategies.
• There is a need for local structures such as district and local
municipalities to be more involved in the affairs of small
businesswomen.
• Police do not act when cases of domestic violence are reported to
them.
• There are many problems with regard to traditional marriages in
rural areas and there is a need to align traditional practices with
the rights enshrined in the Constitution.
- Visits to farms
5.1 Visit to the Thathunyawo Cane and Citrus Farm and the Phezukomkhono Women’s Co-operative
The visit took place on 2 November 2004 and included the Hon Ms J L Kgoali; the Hon Prof L Ndabandaba, KwaZulu-Natal MEC for Agriculture and Environmental Affairs; Members of the Provincial Legislature of KwaZulu- Natal and Councillors of the Uthungulu District Municipality; Prof Mtshali of the University of Zululand; Mr Biyela, Chairperson of Thathunyawo Co- operative; Mr Mtimkulu; Ms S Mkhize, Chairperson of the Phezukomkhono Women’s Co-operative
5.1 Background of the Phezukomkhono Women’s Co-operative
• The co-operative has 46 members; it bought the co-operative farm of
200 ha of land for R3,7 million.
• Each member of the co-operative received R35 000 from the National
Ministry of Land and Agriculture, while the co-operative received a
loan of R1,2 million from the Land Bank.
• Initially, the co-operative had 85 employees, but due to financial
difficulty some of the employees had to be retrenched and the
members of the co-operative received no remuneration for six
months.
• The co-operative approached the MEC for Agriculture and
Environmental Affairs for financial assistance, focusing on the
following six areas of assistance: (i) insecticides (ii) manure
(iii) a tractor and a car (iv) a monthly instalment of R33 000 (for
repayment of the Land Bank loan) (v) a R100 000 electricity bill
(vi) R120 000 to be paid to the municipality for the co-operative’s
water bill.
5.2 The Phezukomkhono women’s co-operative
• The aforementioned co-operative commenced its activities four years
ago, at a time when 52 co-operatives were active in the
agricultural field in the Phezukomkhono area.
• The co-operative started with 11 members on a farm of 269 ha
purchased on an auction for R750 000.
• The Department of Trade and Industry and the provincial department
funded the co-operative, and the centre was opened by the MEC for
Land and Environmental Affairs.
• The provincial department provided 300 000 chickens for farming and
a chicken mash.
• The co-operative secured 120 000 tons of orders for next year, and
it had no difficulty in accessing markets, including overseas
markets.
• The co-operative was planning further developments in future and
still requires a tractor for paprika production.
5.3 Challenges
The following two challenges were identified:
• Inadequate training for those who had acquired the land.
• Assistance by the MEC with capacity-building and skill-training
programmes.
5.4 Response by the MEC to the challenges
• The MEC gave an undertaking that his department would provide a
tractor, made possible through a departmental project called
“Mechanism Department”.
• The MEC undertook to revisit the farm on 16 November 2004.
• The Department has a mentorship programme in place to assist people
in acquiring the requisite skills and that mentors will be able to
facilitate communication by speaking Zulu.
The Chairperson of the NCOP emphasised the importance of this women-led project and donated R1 000 to it.
5.5 Visit to Amangwe Village and Sokhulu Community Garden
The visit took place on 2 November 2004. Mr MJ Mahlangu, Deputy Chairperson of the National Council of Provinces led the delegation, which visited the Amangwe Village and the Sokhulu Community Garden.
5.5.1 Background to Amangwe Village
Amangwe village is a partnership-driven initiative, which recognizes that HIV/Aids is much more than just a health issue. The project aims to provide support to adults and children infected and affected by HIV/Aids through a range of interventions. The opportunity to establish Amangwe Village came about when Monde approached the ZCBF with a veritable dream come true, the offer of Amangwe Village in Kwambonambi - previously used by their contract workers to be developed into a holistic HIV/Aids initiative. The offer came at a time when ZCBF was looking at options for the expansion of its already successful HIV/Aids projects, Ethembeni Care Centre.
Today Ethembeni Care Centre operates from a purpose built facility at Amangwe Village, which also boasts, a training room, administration block and 18 renovated cottages, which are used for a variety of services. Important working relationships have also been established with amongst others, the Africa Centre for Population Studies, the Department of Health, Welfare and Education, Lifeline Zululand and KZN Wildlands Trust. Extensive continued networking with other important stakeholders and government and government departments is ongoing.
Orphans And Vulnerable Children Services
The primary objectives of this arm of Amangwe Village are: the protection of children, their inheritance and property rights; improving the capacity of primary caregivers to meet the basic need of the children in their care; ensuring the self reliance of care givers; and ensuring that traumatised children are dealt with in a professional and holistic manner.
Outreach, Education And Training
Through outreach, education and training initiatives, Amangwe Village aims to achieve three main objectives:
• Provides services to communities outside of the confines of Amangwe
Village through its Homes-Based Care, which comprises well-trained
volunteer caregivers who daily visit poverty stricken households to
assist in caring for critically ill loved ones.
• Aims to assist affected families with income generation through
skills training and supports community-based projects. Initial work
in this area has centred primarily around the establishment of
rural food gardens to provide produce for a centrally based rural
Health Food Store, which is soon to b opened at Amangwe Village.
• Generation of income for Amangwe Village itself through the
delivery of workplace HIV/Aids programmes to businesses in the
region
5.5.2 Visit To Sokhulu Community Garden
This is a community project, which practises organic farming. It serves to provide food for orphans and poverty-stricken families. There are three persons involved in the project.
The project is struggling due to lack of funds. There is no sufficient water supply and they use buckets for watering. The site is not easily accessible as there are no roads.
Meeting with Farmers
The meeting with farmers took place on 2 November 2004 and was addressed by the Honourable Rev P Moatshe, Chairperson of the Select Committee on Land and Environmental Affairs; the Honourable Prof L Ndabandaba, KwaZulu-Natal MEC for Agriculture and Environmental Affairs; Mr H Lee (Felix Cane Growers Association); Mr P Addison, Chairperson of the SA Can Growers Association; Mr G Green, Treasurer of the SA Cane Growers Association; Dr M Buthelezi, Chairperson of the Emerging Farmers Association and the National Farmers Union; representatives from the National Agricultural Co-operative Sector of South Africa; and a representative from the emerging farmers.
The Department highlighted the following programmes and successes:
• Nthingi tea plantation provides 1 000 jobs. Each hectare provides
ten fulltime jobs.
• Intensive programme of developing the SMME sector: This programme
involves at least 500 emerging contractors. There are new areas
coming into production, such as ploughing and haulage, which earned
R7 million in the year 2003-04. Forty-six tractor units have been
handed out during the 2003-04 financial year, with the minimum area
ploughed per tractor being 250 ha. The Department is envisioning to
create 12 000 jobs.
• Liming and soil fertility programme: 660 ha have been treated,
which has created 666 new jobs. The restoration of eroded land and
the filling of dongas on 2 000 ha have provide 2 000 job
opportunities.
• Animal handling programme: Through this programme 94 dipping tanks
have been rehabilitated in 2004, at a cost of R1, 4 million. Each
rehabilitated tank creates 10 jobs, thus 940 new jobs have been
created.
• Mentorship programme: This has been established to encourage and
train black emerging farmers.
• Agri-economics: It has been discovered that the simplest African
crop, the amadumbe, has many uses, and thus the Department is
researching and exploring a variety of uses. The Department will
also be encouraging farmers to plant amadumbe as a cash crop.
• Eradication of alien weed programme: The Department has asked the
Premier and Treasury for additional funds for this project. The aim
is to clear 4 000 ha per annum. This would result in 15 to 20 jobs
per ha, and because 80 000 person-hours is needed a further 8 000
jobs can be created.
• Dam-building project: Three dams are being built at Bululwana,
Makhatini and Pongola. These dams will be used for irrigation and
will provide 500 jobs.
• Capacity building: Sixty-five applications have been received from
farmers to participate in the capacity-building programme. In each
case 10 jobs per farm will be created.
• Women and Youth Project in Agriculture: There are presently 222
projects, each providing eight jobs, and totalling 1 776 new jobs.
• Mushroom and Dry Land Rice Production Project: the Chinese
Government has lent its assistance to the project. The project
produces dry land rice and mushrooms and has 15 field workers at
R70 000 each. There are also five field worker managers who
collectively earn R450 000. This is generating private employment,
which will create another 450 jobs for farm workers.
6.1 Challenges
• Unemployment, which consequently leads to high crime statistics.
• The requirements of labour legislation, such as minimum wages and
other conditions of employment requirements, often lead to job
losses and other costs, which small-scale growers cannot afford.
• No training was given to communities when co-operatives were
initially established resulting in poor management of co-
operatives.
• A lack of adequate infrastructure, such as roads, hampered access
to and from cane fields.
• The strengthening of the South African currency affected cane
farming’s profitability.
• The usage of inferior seeds resulted in the usage of fertilizers
and herbicides, which were expensive due to the strength of the
rand.
6.2 Recommendations
• The dedicated buy-in of the Amakhosi and Izinduna with the people
of each isigodi to identify suitable land and Zulu farmers,
preferably from within their own area to lease and farm such
identified land.
• The appointment of extension officers who understand agri-economics
and will drive that department in a new and decisive manner, using
the existing commercial farmers as mentors through a system of
District Agricultural Committees, down to Municipal Agricultural
Committees. Organised agriculture in KwaZulu-Natal had already
started with a similar process, but could not maintain the idea due
to a lack of funding. This needs to be brought under the control of
local municipalities, with funding from the Department of
Agriculture in order to achieve effective results.
• The Department of Transport needs to allocate a large portion of
its budget to assist in selected (I D P) areas in agricultural
development in the Amakhosi areas through the building of roads and
causeways to move agricultural crops to mills and/or markets.
- Public Hearing on the Expanded Public Works Programme, including Sustainable Subsistence Farming
The meeting on the Expanded Public Works Programme, including issues related to sustainable subsistence farming, took place on 2 November 2004 at Empangeni.
The meeting was addressed by the following speakers: Hon Deputy Minister of Public Works Prof N Kganyago, Hon MEC for Transport and Safety and Security Cele, Hon MEC for Public Works Gwala.
The following issues were raised during the session:
7.1 Halving unemployment and poverty by 2014
• Government has set itself the goal of halving unemployment and poverty
by 2014. Joblessness and lack of income represent the glaring face of
poverty, which manifests through lack of access to basic and essential
services, lack of free education, lack of infrastructure including
houses and roads and lack of skills, qualifications and education to
enable people to take up available job opportunities.
• Since 1994 government has put in place programmes to improve the
quality of life of communities. Examples are free public health care
for pregnant women and children up to six years, feeding schemes for
learners at deserving schools, free basic services for poor
households, the child support grant, the roll out of drugs against HIV
and AIDS and other initiatives to fight poverty.
• Government also convened the Growth and Development Summit in 2003 to
discuss with business, labour and civil society, plans and strategies
to create jobs, improve the lives of people and eradicate poverty.
• The Expanded Public Works Programme (EPWP) is one of the Government’s
most important strategies specifically designed to support the
objective of job creation for poverty alleviation. This programme
targets the poor, women, youth and people with disabilities for
employment opportunities. The target is 60% women, 30% youth and 2%
disabled.
• The EPWP was officially launched by President Mbeki on 18 May 2004 at
Giyani in Limpopo. All nine provincial governments have launched their
EPWP.
7.2 Goals of the EPWP
• The EPWP is one of government’s initiatives to create jobs, develop
skills, improve communities and draw the marginalised poor people out
of the spiral of poverty.
• According to President Mbeki, “EPWP is a nation wide programme which
will draw significant numbers of unemployed into productive work, so
that workers gain skills while working, and increase their capacity to
earn an income”.
• It therefore seeks to create significant work opportunities that will
engage the unemployed in productive activities and, at the same time,
equip them with skills that will allow them to find continuous
employment outside the EPWP. The programme is about skilling the
nation and creating a platform for increased growth and development.
• The primary objective is to use existing public sector funds to
provide as many unemployed locals as possible with an opportunity to
earn an income, gain work experience and acquire job-related training
and skills development.
• Government departments, provinces, municipalities and other government
institutions including state-owned enterprises, must expand the
absorption capacity of existing government programmes to create one
million job opportunities in the next five years. Labour intensive
methods will be used to produce and deliver services such as road
construction, maintenance of public buildings, environmental clean-ups
and caring for the terminally ill and other sick people in the
communities using home-based care givers.
• Both local and provincial governments, because of their proximity to
the communities, are expected to identify new and existing
opportunities for the creation of jobs.
7.3 The nature of EPWP projects
• The EPWP differs from similar programmes before it. The EPWP
emphasises skills development to address the problem of unemployment.
Workers will be given accreditable and recognisable qualifications
while employed on these projects as part of the skills they can and
will use at the end of the projects as they seek opportunities
elsewhere within the realms of the country’s growing economy.
• Government-established Sector Education and Training Authorities
(SETAs) have been mobilised to train would-be employers, supervisors
and employees in the EPWP. The idea is to train them in
labour–intensive technologies so that they produce and deliver good
quality services and products while using labour instead of machines.
• The National Department of Public Works, which is coordinating the
EPWP, is currently communicating with, and meeting with provinces,
municipalities and community development organisations to familiarise
them with the requirements, methodologies and expectations of the
programme.
7.4 Progress made in implementing the EPWP
• To date, reports indicate that at least 38 000 work opportunities were
created in the first quarter, that is, between April and June 2004, at
a total salary cost of more than R33 million. Work is in progress to
firm up the monitoring and reporting systems under the EPWP. This will
aid precise data collection and improve projections.
• As the Provinces and Municipalities begin to fully comprehend the
requirements of the EPWP and its relationship to provisional grants
such as the Provincial and Municipal Infrastructure Grant, more
resources will be allocated to projects and programmes within
communities, which have the propensity to create jobs and other
training opportunities. Community members are encouraged to talk to
their local representatives about EPWP and any other government
interventions to fight poverty, diseases, hunger, illiteracy and
underdevelopment.
• It was noted that the EPWP is not a Department of Public Works
programme, but that of government as a whole and therefore the entire
nation needs to embrace it. A successfully implemented EPWP will
create jobs, enhance skills and contribute to reducing the gap between
the rich and the poor.
• Municipalities and their relevant structures are requested to become
activists for the EPWP ensure that as many work opportunities as
possible are built to create a better life for all.
7.5 Launch of the EPWP in KwaZulu Natal
On 28 August 2004, the Province of KwaZulu-Natal launched a Provincial EPWP programme against the backdrop of the Department of Transport’s following flagship programmes: Zibambele (Doing it for Ourselves), Vukuzakhe (Arise and build yourself) and Labour-Based Road Construction.
7.5.1 Zibambele
The project was initiated in 2000 with a budget of R10 million. It is a poverty alleviation programme using labour intensive road maintenance methods. It targets the poorest of the poor, mostly women-headed households especially those headed by widows; 93%-95% of the contracts have been awarded to women and are renewed annually for permanent or sustainable income training. There are 22 208 women on this programme.
7.5.2 Vukuzakhe
This is an emerging contractor development programme. It is a four-stage advancement programme. There are approximately 1 000 contracts awarded annually. The budget for this programme has grown from R49 million in the 1998-99 financial year to R410 million in 2003-04 financial year. The programme has created more than 100 000 jobs in the past five years.
Vukuzakhe has some contracts maximising labour absorption. These are:
• Verge maintenance; cleaning of pipes, kerbs and channels.
• Guardrail installation and repairs.
• Construction of pipe and concrete culverts.
• Construction of kerbs and channels.
• Construction of sidewalks.
• Construction and gabion repairs.
There is capacity building with respect to the following: business development, technical training, organisational development and there are also 100 Construction Education and Training Authority (CETA) learnerships.
7.5.3 Labour Based Road Construction projects
The Department has allocated R25 million for fourteen new projects in 2004-
- There are 63 kilometres of roads to be constructed and 3 1510 roads to be created. The funding targets municipalities with poverty levels of 60%- 80%, especially women and youth.
Approximately 83 students have been trained to supervise work, creating a pool of expertise in the construction industry accredited for labour, to be sourced through CETA. This is to stimulate and encourage the local manufacture of tools and the supply of materials. The emphasis is on skills development to eradicate unemployability. This programme is also divided into sectors such as social, economic, infrastructure and environmental and cultural sectors.
The total for sector budgets is R619,4 million. The sector budgets are as follows:
Social sector R53,7 million Economic sector R0,7 million Infrastructure sector R495,4 million Environmental and cultural sector R69,6 million
The profit generated in the Empangeni district alone is R119 million.
The Department of Public Works has other programmes, other than the EPWP, facilitated by the Department of Transport, which include the following:
• Hiring and construction of land.
• Poverty alleviation programmes to assist people in the rural areas, in
particular. These programmes include (i) Wangenisa for women and (ii)
Ushikishi for the youth.
• People are also encouraged to do craftwork.
7.6 Challenges
The following questions and concerns were raised by the members of the community:
• There is a problem with regard to the construction and maintenance of
roads in the province, many of which are not properly tarred. It is
believed that improper tarring contributes to most accidents.
• Concern was expressed that when National Ministers visit the Province
to launch any project in areas such as Durban and Pietermaritzburg
they communicate with the mayors, but in rural areas such as Tungulu
and others they go straight to the people.
• The specific experience of a group who had attempted to start a skills
training school where beds, desks, and other furniture was
manufactured, was articulated. The group claimed that because the
promised government assistance, through the Department of Labour, had
not been received, the school had to be closed and the property has
since been vandalised.
• There are concerns about the process of employing people for projects.
• Tenders are inaccessible, except to many of the larger companies.
• Concern was raised that tenders appear to be given to government
officials and even school principals. These officials are also alleged
to be stumbling blocks to service delivery.
• There was a concern that people are politising government projects and
allocating them to people belonging to certain political parties.
• One resident complained that the funds she had been allocated to start
a crèche in Ndlangubo were later withdrawn.
• The experience of a group of employees from Richards Bay was
articulated. In 2001 the group organised themselves to build
cupboards, desks and other school furniture, but were evicted by the
owner of the building because they were unable to pay rent of R3 000 a
month for four months.
• Further details were sought on government’s plan to deal with corrupt
officials.
• Details were sought on the programme of training of Community
Development Workers (CDW), and whether the programme has started yet.
• The youth expressed concern about their welfare. They asked whether
government has any programme focusing on youth in Grade 12 who have no
funding to further their studies.
7.7 Response by the Hon MEC Cele (Transport and Safety and Security KZN) and the Hon MEC Gwala (Public Works KZN) to these concerns:
• It was noted that, with regard to the tarring of roads, when the
engineers inspect the roads they prioritise danger zones, due to a
lack of funds, and those danger zones are tarred first.
• It was acknowledged that financing of projects is a problem because of
the syndrome of politicising the projects. The MEC warned that this
practice should be stopped as these projects are meant to be allocated
without regard to political affiliations.
• The criteria for employing people to work on the roads construction
and maintenance projects are black women, those who are elderly and
widows, in particular. People in the communities are given an
opportunity to employ these people.
• The community was requested to report cases where they were
experiencing problems with the financing of projects, the awarding of
tenders, and so forth, to the relevant Department.
• The community was requested to submit their projects’ business plans
to the relevant Department, in particular to the MEC’s office, for
assistance.
• It was noted that the challenge of the youth who need financial
assistance to further their studies rests with the Department of
Education. The Department of Public Works assists those who study
architecture, civil, electrical and mechanical engineering and
quantity surveying. An amount of R30 million has been set aside for
this purpose. There is also an assistance programme such as the
Tertiary Education Fund of South Africa (TEFSA) to assist students.
• The community was advised to contact their Member of Parliament and
Members of the Provincial Legislature when they have problems prior to
meetings of this nature.
• The Chairperson of the NCOP’s Select Committee on Public Services
noted the problems raised and the fact that some are general issues
cutting across all provinces.
- Public Hearing on Poverty Alleviation and Educational and Social Needs
The meeting took place on 3 November 2004 and was addressed by the Honourable Ms N Botha (Deputy Minister of Arts and Culture), Dr J Benjamin, (Deputy Minister of Social Development), Mr MKN Gigaba (Deputy Minister of Home Affairs) and Dr M Tshabalala-Msimang (Minister of Health).
8.1 Poverty alleviation and social needs in Arts and Culture
The Deputy Minister pointed out that the Department was engaged in programmes aimed at restoring the dignity of the culture of all the people in South Africa. These programmes could also serve as tools for poverty alleviation and creating social cohesion. Rural development through Arts and Culture has been a key focus in the Department. Community arts centres have been built in rural communities as an initiative towards poverty alleviation, with the additional aim of utilising them as centres for the transfer of skills and information.
8.2 Promoting Arts and Culture through Social Cohesion
The Arts and Culture in Society Unit facilitates strategic support to arts institutions and civil society organisations. It involves developing the arts, but also plays an important role in addressing issues of inclusion and integration and to removing disparities in the resourcing of the Arts and Culture Sector. Playhouses, funding bodies and community arts centres receive grants to run programmes and to develop arts and culture.
8.3 Promoting linguistic diversity
South Africa’s linguistic diversity is supported by constitutional commitments to protecting language rights and promoting its indigenous languages. In 2003 Cabinet approved the National Language Policy Framework, comprising a policy statement, implementation plan and a language code of conduct for South Africa. The Policy Framework promotes the equitable use of 11 official languages, and targets all government structures. Provinces will formulate their own policies according to regional circumstances. The policy will be phased in progressively.
8.4 International Partnerships
The Department participates in all binational commissions between South Africa and its foreign partners with the aim of securing foreign development aid programmes and international agreements or partnerships. The Department is in the process of registering as a member of the Commonwealth Foundation on behalf of South Africa, which will further strengthen international opportunities to leverage skills and resources.
8.5 Transformation of the heritage sector
The establishment of the South African Heritage Resource Agency as a statutory body in 2002 and the National Heritage Council in 2003 has made better management of heritage resources and the transformation of the sector possible. A lead project in this area is the proposed Nkosi Albert Luthuli Museum in KwaDukuza. The Cabinet has approved a number of other legacy projects to start correcting distortions in the representation of specific aspects of the country’s history, to encourage nation building, and to contribute towards tourism development. Disbursements are also being paid to assist institutions with transformation processes.
8.6 Archives
The National Archives and Records Service of South Africa subprogramme has made substantial progress in implementing its objectives of good governance and transformation, meeting the information needs of society at large and promoting national reconciliation through the transformation of heraldic and other symbols. The National Council for Library and Information Services (NCLS) was established in November 2003, and its inaugural meeting was held in March 2004.
8.7 Supporting cultural industries
• The Cultural Industries Growth Strategy capitalises on the economic
potential of the craft, music, film, publishing, and design
industries. Departmental support goes towards developing public-
private partnerships and initiatives, using culture as a tool for
urban regeneration and efforts to co-ordinate the industries. There
is an increased focus on the potential of the film industry.
• A special poverty relief allocation aims at providing access to
skills and markets as a tool for urban regeneration, rural
development, and job creation. Projects are undertaken in
partnership with provincial and local government, as well as non-
governmental organisations. The Wild Coast, Lebombo, and Maputo
Corridor spatial development initiatives are focal areas of
cultural tourism development linked to this allocation.
The following are among the objectives of the subprogramme:
o Creating opportunities for musicians, performers, crafters
and artists to contribute to the economy.
o Contributing to the sustainability of the projects by
providing the necessary training (product development,
entrepreneurial skills).
o Developing infrastructure in order to promote enterprise
development.
o Supporting heritage development projects.
o Creating employment for rural-based women in KwaZulu-Natal,
Eastern Cape, Free State and North West.
• The Department of Arts and Culture with its mandate is addressing
the following types of poverty:
o Asset Poverty: by providing capital for raw material (beads,
materials, etc) and in extreme cases, for infrastructure
development.
o Skills Poverty: by providing access to training and
learnerships (human resources development). To this effect
the MAPSETA has developed nine learnerships ranging from SQA
2 to 9.
o Income Poverty: by providing support to income-generating
enterprises and supporting the establishment of sustainable
SMMEs.
o Markets: an integrated approach to accessing markets for SA
projects and services has been adopted. Public-private
initiatives including state-owned entities and NGOs (Cape
Craft Design Institute).
o Products from some of the Investing in Culture Projects are
available from retail stores like Woolworths and abroad
through a partnership with Conran Marketing. Projects
involved are from the Eastern Cape (six villages in Mount
Ayliff and Burgersdorp) and Limpopo (Twananani, Mbokota in
Louis Trichardt, Makosha in Giyani and Vuhlalu in Acornhoek).
• The Department, in conjunction with the municipalities, is
establishing Arts and Culture desks in each municipality.
8.8 Poverty alleviation in Social Development
• The Department of Social Development is committed to halving
poverty in our country by the year 2015. One of the ways government
addresses income poverty is through transfers of R50 billion a year
in social assistance in the form of social grants. This is
Government’s most effective antipoverty programme, and currently
reaches over eight million of the poorest South Africans.
• The Department is also pursuing its objective of moving away from a
welfare-type approach to a more developmental approach, because the
government believes that the focus should be on creating an
enabling environment for people to develop themselves and be self-
sustaining.
• Fighting poverty requires the building of strong partnerships right
across the country. The Department has, for example, built
partnerships with faith-based organisations in order to reach the
furthest corners of our country, where many of our people live in
conditions of abject poverty. These partnerships have enabled the
Department over the past few years to increase the number of
children receiving the child support grant to more than four
million.
• The Department believes that a strong civil society is a
prerequisite for people-centred development. The Department is
committed to improving the quality of support provided to the NGO
sector and urges all NGOs to play their part in fighting poverty
and underdevelopment.
• In the past few weeks the Deputy Minister of Social Development and
the Deputy Minister of Home Affairs have travelled to various parts
of the country visiting various communities as part of a mass
registration drive for identity documents (IDs) and birth
certificates. Through this mass registration drive, thousands of
previously disadvantaged people have been able to have access to
Government services for the first time.
• HIV and Aids present the government with an enormous challenge, as
whole families are being affected. The provision of antiretroviral
treatment is just one part of the government’s comprehensive
response. Support for home community-based care initiatives is
another important component of the Department’s response. The issue
of child-headed households is of particular concern to the
Department. Research is being conducted to look into this issue and
programmes are being put in place to address the situation.
• In KwaZulu-Natal, the Department is working with the National
Association of Child and Youth Care Workers to alleviate the plight
of children affected by HIV and Aids. The Department has also
helped establish drop-in centres for orphaned and vulnerable
children.
• Public hearings have been held on the Children’s Bill and the
national Department of Social Development is currently costing the
Bill. There are unfortunately still a high number of children in
custody in KwaZulu Natal and the Minister of Social Development has
instructed that these cases must be cleared and children in
conflict with the law placed in appropriate institutions before the
end of the year.
• The Department of Social Development is also acutely concerned
about the problems faced by youth in their efforts to develop
themselves. The biggest challenges facing youth are skills
development, job opportunities and employment. The Department of
Social Development participates in the Expanded Public Works
Programme and is involved in skills enhancement and enhanced
service provision through the Early Childhood Development programme
and the Home Community-Based Care programme. The job opportunities
created may be of a temporary nature, but they are a step towards
more sustainable employment.
• From the 25th November, Government will once more be engaged in 16
Days of Activism to combat violence against women and children.
This campaign signals the fact that South Africans from all sectors
of society are uncompromising in their fight against gender
violence.
8.9 Department of Home Affairs response to issues of poverty and social needs
• The presentation noted that the Department of Home Affairs played a
crucial role in ensuring that, with the aid of the correct identity
documentation, people are able to access both Government and
private sector services.
• The legacy of the Department’s role in enforcing apartheid-era
racial classifications will still be felt for a long time to come.
There are still thousands of South Africans who have never had a
birth certificate or an ID. This makes it impossible for people to
access social security grants, educational opportunities or
employment opportunities.
• The Department of Home Affairs is engaged in a number of
interventions to meet these challenges:
o A survey will be conducted to determine the approximate
number of people without IDs or children without birth
certificates to allow for proper planning and allocation of
resources.
o Another wave of the intensive drive for IDs and birth
certificates will be launched. The Department has acted in
partnership with other government departments, such as the
Department of Social Development and the provinces during
many of its community outreach campaigns.
o The Department will launch a campaign to rectify the
information it has about the citizens, especially the dates
of birth, in order to correct the Population Register.
o The online birth registration campaign has been launched in
the hospitals and clinics in order to ensure that children
obtain their birth certificates soon after birth. This will
ensure that their parents can apply immediately for child
support grants if they qualify. This latter programme has
already been launched in KZN and Limpopo Provinces, and will
be launched gradually in 58 hospitals countrywide during this
financial year and to extend it to as many hospitals and
clinics as possible, depending on the availability of
resources over the next few years, and to ensure that every
child born will be registered and issued with a birth
certificate before they leave for home with their parents.
• In addition, the Department is also attending to the following:
o The urgent challenge to resolve the capacity problems in the
Department, among others, through the recruitment of new
staff and retraining of the current staff to meet the
objectives of Batho Pele.
o Addressing corruption in the Department inter alia through
employing the necessary people and establishing co-operation
mechanisms with other state agencies to help eradicate this
problem. The Department is calling on the public to assist
them in this campaign.
o Funds have been made available for the construction of new
offices, transforming containers into offices and purchasing
67 mobilise units fully fitted with modern equipment to be
deployed to all the provinces, especially in the far-flung
areas to assist with the ID drive and the provision of other
services.
8.10 Department of Health response to issues of poverty and social needs
• The Health Department has focused on development aid for primary
health care in the identified rural nodes and has engaged other
partners to assist in strengthening primary care in these areas. To
this end, dedicated health co-ordinators have been deployed in each
of the 13 districts, focusing on achieving functional integration
of primary health care services and strengthening of programmes to
tackle the diseases of poverty.
• Departments involved in the Social Cluster have worked together in
their efforts to address issues of food security and nutrition. The
Department of Health contributed to this process by strengthening
the Primary School Feeding Scheme. The programme was already
reaching 4,7 million children at 15 000 schools when it was
transferred to the Department of Education. It was estimated to
reach 87% of targeted children and had led to improved school
attendance and attentiveness of learners.
• The compulsory fortification of basic foodstuffs such as mielie
meal, bread and wheat flour with micronutrients, including iron and
vitamin A, is a major achievement in improving the nutritional
status of South Africans. The Department has also allocated R 7
million for nutritional supplements to be distributed to those in
need and a campaign to encourage healthy diets, regular exercise
and other healthy habits in the general population is underway.
• The underlying factor in the spread of infectious diseases
including HIV and AIDS, TB and malaria is the poor conditions under
which most of those who are infected and affected live. In
responding to these challenges, the Department highlighted the
central role of prevention. Campaigns to encourage abstinence and
ensure that those in sexual relationships are faithful to one
partner are proceeding well. Distribution of newly branded male
condoms has increased from 33 million to 45 million condoms per
month since June 2003. Sites for voluntary counselling and testing
have doubled from 1 500 in March 2004 to more than 3000 at the end
of September.
• The utilisation of the AIDS Help-line that provides information on
HIV and AIDS and refers people to available services has increased
to 5 000 calls per day.
• Access to AIDS-related treatment is being extended across the
country with 50 of the 53 districts having at least one service
point for management, care and treatment of HIV and AIDS. A total
of 102 health facilities have been accredited to provide a number
of services aimed at mitigating the impact of HIV and AIDS
including antiretroviral therapy. Efforts are also being made to
determine the impact of traditional medicines in improving the
health of people with HIV and AIDS.
• The Department is increasing efforts to combat TB, which remains a
major challenge in the country. The interventions are focused on
better case management and providing support for those on TB
treatment because TB is curable even in the presence of HIV.
• The Department has continued to make progress in reducing malaria
within South Africa and through collaborative efforts with its
neighbouring countries. Since the inception of the malaria control
project within the Lubombo Spatial Development Initaitive four
years ago, malaria incidents have been reduced by 96% in KZN, 91%
in Swaziland and 86% in the participating areas of Mozambique.
• The Department is addressing the issue of access to safe water and
proper sanitation, as the shortcomings in this regard still expose
poor communities to various health risks, including cholera.
• Noncommunicable diseases, such as diabetes, hypertension, cancer
and osteoporosis are increasingly being recognised as global health
problems. Many developing countries face a growing burden of
chronic, noncommunicable diseases - and South Africa is one of
them. The Department's priority over the next five years is to
develop meaningful programmes for preventing these diseases that
are difficult to live with and costly to manage. The strategies for
prevention are the same for many noncommunicable diseases – they
centre on good diet, responsible alcohol consumption, regular
exercise and avoiding tobacco use. Government is finalising a
policy framework that will contribute to responsible alcohol
consumption.
• As its contribution to tightening the social security net for the
poor, the Department has added free health care for people with
disabilities to the package of free health services targeted
initially at pregnant women, children under six and all those
accessing primary health care.
• The Department is intensifying the implementation of the Expanded
Programme on Immunisation to ensure that children are protected
from vaccine-preventable diseases like measles and that South
Africa can be declared polio-free by the end on 2005.
• Access to cervical and breast cancer screening is being expanded
and the main factors contributing to maternal mortality are being
monitored closely to inform further policy interventions aimed at
improving the health of women. The Department is also extending
cancer-screening services to cover prostate cancer as well.
• The other programmes that the Department is involved in include:
o Improving access to affordable medicine.
o Increasing access to medical cover and ensuring that medical
schemes are financially sustainable.
o Hospital Revitalisation Programme that improves hospital
infrastructure, availability of equipment and management
capacity.
o Various efforts to recruit and retain health workers and
improve their capacity to meet the needs of the community as
health is a labour-intensive sector.
8.11 Replies and response
• In response to the concerns that were raised during the questions
from the floor, the presenters and panellists highlighted the
following issues:
o The child-support grants are to be used for the benefit of
the child, not for the parents or grandparents. Members of
the public should report those cases where parents or
grandparents were using the money for their own purposes
since that amounted to corruption.
o The issue of teenage pregnancies must be addressed. Parents
should look at why families have lost their values and have
taken on other cultures either voluntarily or by being forced
to do so.
o The Department of Education in KwaZulu-Natal had a policy
that all schools whether rural or urban had to be given equal
treatment. Rural schools are not deliberately being
neglected. The Department was particularly concerned about
the impact of the drought because it had resulted in some
schools simply being without water. The MEC was dealing with
the matter together with other role-players.
- Meeting with Youth and People with Disabilities
The meeting with youth and people with disabilities took place on 3 November 2004. The following speakers addressed meeting:
Mr Jabu Mbalula, (Chairperson of National Youth Commission), Mr. Mbongeni Mtshali, (Director of Business Development Services in Umsobomvu Youth Fund, Dr. E. Kornegeay, (Office on the Status of Women), and Mr. Philip Gamede (Provincial Treasurer of the Disabled People South Africa (DPSA). All the presenters provided contextual information on the establishment of key organisations aimed at improving the lives of the youth and people with disabilities. In this regard, the presentations highlighted the various programmes undertaken, as well as challenges facing organisations in the delivery of services to the youth and disabled persons.
9.1 National Youth Commission
The National Youth Commission was established in June 1996, after the Youth Summit that was convened by President Thabo Mbeki, aimed at empowering the youth as part of Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP). It was agreed that the Presidency had to ensure that government also consider youth issues in their programmes in order to ensure the creation of youth programmes at provincial and local levels.
The responsibilities and roles of the Commission are enshrined in the National Commission Act of 1996. Some of the objectives of the Commission are to:
• Co-ordinate and develop an integrated National Youth Commission.
• Develop an integrated national plan that utilises available resources
and expertise for the development of young women and children. These
are integrated within the RDP.
• Develop principles and guidelines, and make recommendations to the
government for the implementation of the National Youth Policy.
• Promote uniformity of approach to issues affecting youth by all organs
of State, including provincial governments.
• Co-ordinate the activities of the various provincial government
institutions involved in youth matters.
• Implement measures to redress the imbalances of the past, in relation
to various forms of disadvantages suffered by young people generally
or by specific groups or categories.
The Focal Areas of the Commission include:
• Economic empowerment of the youth.
• The responsibility taken by young people to ensure economic
development in their communities.
• Education and training.
9.1.1 Challenges
Some of the challenges faced by the Commission in realising its objectives are:
• A shortage of tertiary infrastructures.
• Drug abuse.
• On capacity building and advocacy, the challenge should be ensuring
that all government programmes are accessible and relevant to the
youth.
• Assistance given to youth organisations through information that can
help them to access government information.
9.1.2 Interventions
In addressing some of the challenges, a number of interventions that have been introduced. These include:
• The government has introduced and adopted the National Youth Services,
aimed at giving entrepreneurial skills and production of skill to
young people so that they can contribute to economic growth of the
country.
• The Youth Commission has started a pilot programme to provide young
people in prisons with skills.
• The Departments of Justice and Home Affairs have created programmes,
aimed at creating opportunities for graduates to become productive
citizens of the country.
• To date, the Youth Commission and Umsobomvu Youth Fund have recruited
5 000 youth in the Departments of Social Development and Health.
9.2 Umsobomvu Youth Fund
• The Minister of Finance has founded the Umsobomvu Youth Fund,
following the Budget Speech in 1998. The Fund began operating in 2001.
• In 2001, the government established the Youth Commission to create a
platform for job creation and skills development. Umsobomvu Youth
Fund has identified three major programmes areas, namely, Contact
Information and Counselling, Skills Development and Transfer, and
Youth Entrepreneurship.
9.2.1 Programmes
Programmes offered by the Umsobomvu Youth Fund include:
• Access to information and counselling support, with regard to careers,
employment and entrepreneurship opportunities, through Youth Advisory
Centres, Youth Line and the Internet.
• In KwaZulu-Natal, the Umsobomvu Youth Fund supports a youth
development programme called SEED. It has centres in Durban and
Potchefstroom.
• The Fund also provides high-level technical skills and work experience
for unemployed matric and tertiary graduates, with the aim of securing
for them meaningful employment in strategic sectors of the economy.
• The Umsombomvu Youth Fund and the Youth Commission together with
various government departments have been able to create opportunities
for the youth as follows:
o The National Youth Support Programme has to date offered
opportunities for 5 000 young people. Young people have
received training, which has equipped them with the skills
and experience they need to achieve economic independence,
while completing a service project that contributes to
national or local development objectives.
o For the year 2004-2005, another 5 000 young people will be
involved in youth service initiatives in health, social
development, infrastructure development, agriculture and
nature conservation sectors. The table below provides
information on Lead projects funded by Umsobomvu in Kwazulu-
Natal:
Lead Project | Beneficiaries | Committed |
Youth Advisory Centre | 62 861 | R5 837 630 |
School to work | 161 | R5 621 286 |
FET Support Programme | 230 | R4 000 000 |
Youth Service | 281 | R7 320 564 |
Business Development | 4 087 | R6 629 500 |
Service | ||
Entrepreneurship | 1 052 | R 309 241 |
Education | ||
Enterprise finance | 15 (deals) | R10 690 240 |
(SME) | ||
Micro | - | - |
Coops | 65 | R 952 091 |
TOTAL | 65 371 | R41 360 52 |
9.3 Initiatives in the Presidency
• The Office of the President ensures that the programmes deliver
what it has promised. This is done through the Office of the Rights
of the Children and the Office on the Status of the Disabled
People.
• It has to play an oversight function in ensuring that all
government programmes offer equal opportunities for everyone.
• There is also a policy co-ordination and advisory unit. This is
done through the clustering system, by ensuring that programmes
interact with those of government. The intent is to ensure that
these government programmes deliver to people with disabilities and
take cognisance of the rights of children.
• The Presidency has to provide oversight over all government
programmes to ensure that children’s rights are respected, and
people with disabilities have equal opportunities.
• With regard to children, the intent is to ensure that Section 28 of
the Constitution is effected. The Presidency has a programme in
line with Work for Children. The idea is to ensure that the
Constitution is in line with government action.
• Concerning disability, there is an integrated national strategy
incorporated in all policies. For the next 10 years the government
intends to deliver on all these policies. The core functions are
children and disability.
• Within the provinces these programmes are represented in addition
to the focal points in all government departments, except in the
Economic Cluster. The idea is to work with the Departments of
Education, Public Works and Social Development. Looking at what has
been done on children development, consideration is more on the
psychological and emotional development of children and people with
disabilities.
• For the future the emphasis is on facilitation of mainstream
programmes amongst the clusters, and creation of equal
opportunities in Expanded Public Works Programmes for poverty
alleviation.
• The future plans of the Presidency are to add more programmes
within the Economic and Public Services clusters. The Presidency’s
role is to monitor and evaluate these programmes. This is noted as
an important initiative over the next 5 years. The role of the
Presidency is coordination and facilitation of these programmes.
9.4 The Disabled People South Africa (DPSA)
Prior to the 1994 elections, disabled persons suffered double discrimination. The Disabled People South Africa (DPSA) is a national organisation, which represents disabled persons. The DPSA represents the disabled people because organisations that existed to cater for their needs did not represent them well.
The vision of the DPSA is to ensure that the problems of disabled persons are integrated in all programmes. Furthermore, the government policies and rights should provide for all South Africans. The mandate of the DPSA, therefore, is to ensure that all government departments and programmes are accessible and recognise the needs of the disabled.
Representation of disabled persons is also entrenched in the Office of the Premier in all provinces. The government has also established institutions that recognise the rights of all persons, for example the Human Rights Commission, Gender Commission and Youth Commission. In all of these and many others, disabled persons are represented.
The Department of Health has been actively involved in activities of disabled persons. The Department is the only department that gives funding to community-based organisations that support disabled persons. The role of the DPSA is to facilitate the work performed by such organisations. The international day for disabled persons is another indication of commitment by government.
9.4.1 Challenges
The DPSA faces the following challenges:
• Although the DPSA has a structure at national and provincial level,
it does not have at local level.
• Another challenge is that it is difficult for people in rural areas
to contact the provinces. As a facility that can be used, the toll-
free number to report issues or for information, is not helpful.
People experience problems because phones are not accessible and
they may not have the money.
• There is no support for disabled persons from local government
because their needs are not considered.
• The Employment Equity Act is not properly implemented, as many of
the people with disabilities are unemployed. The concern is that
there is no commitment from government departments to ensure that
the disabled are employed. The Department of Labour has developed
the Assistance Guide Framework, but it is not well known to people
with disabilities.
• Capacity building is crucial in order to educate government
officials on how to deal with disabled persons, and also on how
they can help them access government programmes.
• Moreover, the concern is the Constitution that does not recognise
sign language. In many government interviews conducted, members of
the panel are not acquainted with sign language.
• The social justice system does not protect women with disabilities
who are rape victims.
9.4.2 Recommendations
The following recommendations were made:
• The Office on the Status of Disabled people (OSDP) needs to
establish disability desks within the municipalities that are
sensitive to people with disabilities.
• Government should consider sign language as the 12th language.
• In order to create opportunities for disabled persons, all
government departments should employ at least 5% of people with
disabilities.
• The government has to ensure that disabled persons are included in
government programmes, so that they can benefit from them.
- Meeting with Councillors on Local Government Matters
The meeting on local government took place on 4 November 2004. All speakers at the session agreed that local government is appropriately at the centre of government’s national development agenda, as its constitutional mandate is development and distribution of services to the people. The meeting was addressed by the following speakers: Hon the Deputy Minister for Provincial and Local Government Hangana, Hon the Minister of Finance TA Manuel, Hon the MEC: Local Government, Housing and Traditional Affairs M Mabuyakhulu. Hon Councillor Mlabo, Executive Member SALGA, Hon Councillor B Mthethwa and Hon Chairperson of the NCOP JL Kgoali. The session was chaired by Hon S Shiceka, Chairperson of the Local Government Select Committee, as well as Hon MA Khubeka, Chairperson of the KZN Standing Committee on Local Government and Traditional Affairs
10.1 The role of the NCOP in supporting local government
• The NCOP’s vision of developmental local government requires that
the institutional framework for local government be strengthened so
that it can carry out its role of creating “sustainable human
settlements which provide for a decent quality of life and meet the
social, economic and material needs of communities in a holistic
way.”
• Local government is not a third level of government subordinate to
provincial and national government. On the other hand, it is not
completely independent either. It is interrelated with provincial
and national government in a system of co-operative governance in
which the more each sphere co-operates with the other two, the
stronger it becomes.
• The challenge facing the NCOP is to look critically at the
institutional framework and identify aspects that must be enhanced
so as to assist municipalities to effectively play the
developmental role the Constitution envisages they should play.
• During the first decade of freedom significant progress has been
achieved in the areas of housing, basic services, and so forth. In
this regard, government’s significant achievements at local level
have been enabled by the detailed legislative framework that has
been put in place to support all 284 municipalities. The
legislative framework for local government is derived from the
Constitution, which recognises local government as a distinct
sphere of government with both legislative and executive authority
powers.
• National legislation such as the Local Government Municipal
Structures Act, Local Government Municipal Systems Act, the
Municipal Finance Management Act and the Municipal Property Rates
Act, set out the basic principles and mechanisms to give effect to
the vision of developmental local government.
• Both the SALGA National Conference and NCOP Provincial Week (6-10
September 2004) provided the NCOP with a window through which it
can view the challenges confronting municipalities. The events gave
the Council an opportunity to determine how it should respond in
helping municipalities deal with the challenges they are facing.
10.2 Challenges facing local government
• At the SALGA conference President Mbeki alluded to the critical
challenges facing local government. These include attending
expeditiously to service delivery problems identified by
communities, strengthening community participation, co-ordinating
its activities with other spheres of government, putting in place
effective senior management to ensure the implementation of service
delivery objectives, making effective use of the financial and
other resources available, resolving uncertainties around the
functions and powers between local and district municipalities, and
effectively integrating community development workers to support
the work of municipal councils.
• Many of these issues have been raised in the NCOP’s Provincial Week
Report, which presents a broad picture of the capacity of
municipalities. The report seeks to provide a framework for
interaction between the NCOP, provincial and national departments
around these and other key issues.
• The general picture that emerged from the municipalities visited
during the Provincial Week is that they are functioning well, are
delivering services of a high quality and making genuine
contributions towards improving the quality of lives of the
communities they serve. However, there are some municipalities that
continue to face severe constraints in delivering even the most
basic services to the communities they serve. Many municipalities
have no capacity to raise their own revenue and the challenge is to
empower these municipalities to be able to raise their own revenue.
• The NCOP has concluded that the most significant way in it can
respond to the challenges faced by local government is by
strengthening its oversight work. Through its oversight work the
NCOP plays a critical role in ensuring that provincial and national
government continues to provide the institutional support to local
government that it needs to discharge the constitutional
obligations it is entrusted with. This includes making sure that
municipalities have the capacity to implement social and economic
development programmes such as the Expanded Public Works Programme
to help government achieve its objective of halving unemployment
and poverty by 2014.
• Municipalities also have an obligation to ensure they add value to
the efforts being put in by national and provincial government to
capacitate them, by enhancing their delivery of services to
communities.
• Capacity building within municipalities will not automatically
result in enhanced service delivery. It will have to be accompanied
by a conscious effort, total commitment and dedication on the part
of councillors to act as real agents of transformation, to be
servants to communities and not to act in pursuit of self-interest.
• The province itself has drawn up a capacity building programme to
assist Councillors and managers in municipalities.
10.3 Response by the Deputy Minister of Provincial and Local Government to challenges facing local government
10.3.1 Overview of Project Consolidate
In response to all these challenges the Department of Provincial and Local Government (DPLG) has created a legislative framework that would proactively stem the tide and push back the frontiers of poverty. Yet none of the role players in this sector can adequately deal with all these challenges on their own. In recognition of this, DPLG has embarked on Project Consolidate, a targeted hands-on engagement programme to deal with problems facing local government. Through this initiative, municipalities that require the greatest support have been profiled. The intention is to mobilise national and provincial government, state-owned enterprises and the private sector to support the local government.
10.3.2 The focus of Project Consolidate
The profiling exercise indicates that municipalities face legal, financial and administrative challenges in the following areas:
• Public empowerment, participation and community development.
• Capacity building, systems, human resource development and improved
organisational culture.
• The provision of free basic services that target poor households,
appropriate billing systems and reducing municipal debt.
o Local economic development, job creation, Expanded Public
Works Programme and municipal infrastructure.
o Anticorruption initiatives.
o Rural and urban development nodes.
o Performance monitoring, evaluation and communication.
• Other challenges include the low rate of payment of services.
Communities need to be educated on why they should pay for services.
• In terms of the management of municipalities, many municipal managers
and senior managers are not adhering to Batho Pele principles.
Councillors also face certain capacity challenges. Since the Municipal
Finance Management Act provides for the shift of power and
responsibilities to councillors, they require training on budget
management, planning (drawing up of Integrated Development Plans),
financial management and general management issues. Councillors should
be able to communicate council resolutions to the community. They
should be able to identify challenges and draw up an appropriate
programme of action to deal with those challenges.
• It was noted that the direction taken by the DPLG to deal with these
challenges will have a direct impact on the success of the forthcoming
local government elections in 2005-06.
- Conclusion
The NCOP visit to KwaZulu-Natal proved to be very successful and yielded many critical insights. Many valuable lessons were learnt as to how to improve upon initiatives to “Take Parliament to the People”. These lessons will be incorporated into future initiatives of this nature.
Report to be considered.
THURSDAY, 27 JANUARY 2005
TABLINGS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- The Minister of Transport
Report and Financial Statements of the South African Rail Commuter
Corporation Limited (SARCC) for 2003-2004, including the Report of the
Auditor-General on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004 [RP 105-
2004].
- The Minister of Water Affairs and Forestry
(a) Government Notice No 1135 published in Government Gazette No
26848 dated 8 October 2004: Establishment of the Ventersdorp-
Dolomite Water User Association, Magisterial district of Coligny,
Koster, Lichtenburg and Ventersdorp, in the North West Province,
Water Management Area number 9 in terms of the National Water Act,
1998 (Act No 36 of 1998).
(b) Government Notice No 1136 published in Government Gazette No
26848 dated 8 October 2004: Transformation of the Elands Valley
Irrigation Board, Magisterial districts of Belfast, Waterval Boven
and Nelspruit, Mpumalanga Province, into the Elands River
Catchment Area number 5, Mpumalanga Province in terms of the
National Water Act, 1998 (Act No 36 of 1998).
(c) Government Notice No 1138 published in Government Gazette No
26848 dated 8 October 2004: Restrictions on the taking of water
from the Tosca Molopo Dolomite Aquifer in terms of the National
Water Act, 1998 (Act No 36 of 1998).
(d) Government Notice No 1316 published in Government Gazette No
26962 dated 12 November 2004: Proposal for the Establishment of
the Crocodile (West)- Marico Catchment Management Agency in terms
of section 78(3) of the National Water Act, 1998 (Act No 36 of
1998).
(e) Government Notice No 2478 published in Government Gazette No
26962 dated 12 November 2004: Prohibition on the making of fires
in the open air: Districts of Clanwilliam, Piketberg, Ceres,
Tulbagh, Worcester, Caledon, Paarl, Stellenbosch, Strand and
Somerset West in terms of the National Forests Act, 1998 (Act No
84 of 1998).
(f) Government Notice No 2479 published in Government Gazette No
26962 dated 12 November 2004: Prohibition on the making of fires
in the open air: Districts of Swellendam and Montagu in terms of
the National Forests Act, 1998 (Act No 84 of 1998).
(g) Government Notice No 2480 published in Government Gazette No
26962 dated 12 November 2004: Prohibition on the making of fires
in the open air: Western Cape in terms of the National Forests
Act, 1998 (Act No 84 of 1998).
National Council of Provinces
- The Chairperson
(a) Notice received from the MEC for Local Government and Housing
and Traditional Affairs in KwaZulu-Natal regarding the
investigation in the Impendle Municipality in terms of section
106(3) of the Local Government: Municipal Systems Act, 2000 (Act
No 32 of 2000).
(b) Notice received from the MEC for Local Government and Housing
and Traditional Affairs in KwaZulu-Natal regarding an
investigation against the mayor of the Ehlanzeni District
Municipality, in terms of section 106 of the Local Government:
Municipal Systems Act, 2000 (Act No 32 of 2000).
(c) Notice of investigation in Utheka, Umzinyathi and Amajuba
Districts and the Newcastle Municipality, in terms of section 106
of the Local Government: Municipal Systems Act, 2000 (Act No 32 of
2000).
(d) Notice of investigation in Umvoti Municipality in terms of
section 106(3) of the Local Government: Municipal Systems Act,
2000 (Act No 32 of 2000).
(e) Notice of investigation in Umgungundlovu District Municipality
in terms of section 106(3) of the Local Government: Municipal
Systems Act, 2000 (Act No 32 of 2000).
(f) Notice of investigation in Nongoma Municipality in terms of
section 106(3) of the Local Government: Municipal Systems Act,
2000 (Act No 32 of 2000).
(g) Notice of investigation in Umtshezi in terms of section 106(3)
of the Local Government: Municipal Systems Act, 2000 (Act No 32 of
2000).
Referred to the Select Committee on Local Government and
Administration for consideration and report.
Copies of these notices are available from the office of the Clerk
of Papers.
(h) The Acting President of the Republic submitted the following
letter dated 10 January 2005 to the Acting Chairperson of the
National Council of Provinces informing Members of the Council of
the employment of the South African National Defence Force in
Sudan:
EMPLOYMENT OF THE SOUTH AFRICAN NATIONAL DEFENCE FORCE IN SUDAN IN
FULFILLMENT OF THE INTERNATIONAL OBLIGATIONS OF THE REPUBLIC OF
SOUTH AFRICA TOWARDS THE AFRICAN UNION
This serves to inform the National Council of Provinces that I
authorised the employment of the South African National Defence
Force (SANDF) personnel to Sudan for service in fulfilment of the
international obligations of the Republic of South Africa towards
the African Union, as part of the enhanced African Mission in the
Sudan.
This employment was authorised in accordance with the provisions
of section 201(2)(c) of the Constitution of the Republic of South
Africa, 1996 (Act No 108 of 1996), read with section 93 of the
Defence Act, 2002 (Act No 42 of 2002).
A total of 329 members of the SANDF will be deployed for the
mission as from mid-January 2005 to March 2006.
The total estimated cost to be borne by South Africa for the
deployment of personnel to the mission until 31 March 2006 will be
R76 570 247.
I will communicate this report to the Members of the National
Assembly and the Chairperson of the Joint Standing Committee on
Defence, and wish to request that you bring the contents hereof to
the notice of the National Council of Provinces.
Regards
SIGNED
J Z ZUMA
ACTING PRESIDENT
TUESDAY, 1 FEBRUARY 2005
ANNOUNCEMENTS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- Assent by President in respect of Bills
(1) Revenue Laws Amendment Bill [B 24 - 2004] - Act No 32 of 2004
(assented to and signed by President on 18 January 2005);
(2) Second Revenue Laws Amendment Bill [B 25 - 2004] - Act No 34 of
2004 (assented to and signed by President on 18 January 2005); and
(3) Securities Services Bill [B 19B - 2004] - Act No 36 of 2004
(assented to and signed by President on 18 January 2005).
- Introduction of Bills
(1) The Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development
(i) Judicial Matters Amendment Bill [B 2 - 2005] (National
Assembly - sec 75) [Explanatory summary of Bill and prior
notice of its introduction published in Government Gazette No
27001 of 18 November 2004.]
Introduction and referral to the Portfolio Committee on Justice
and Constitutional Development of the National Assembly, as well
as referral to the Joint Tagging Mechanism (JTM) for
classification in terms of Joint Rule 160, on 1 February 2005.
In terms of Joint Rule 154 written views on the classification of
the Bill may be submitted to the Joint Tagging Mechanism (JTM)
within three parliamentary working days.
National Council of Provinces
- Membership of the Council
(1) The vacancy in the representation of the province of KwaZulu-
Natal, which occurred owing to the passing away of Mr N M Raju on
27 October 2004, has been filled with effect from 26 November 2004
by the appointment of Ms A N T Mchunu.
(2) The vacancy in the representation of the province of Gauteng,
which occurred owing to the passing away of Ms J L Kgoali on 21
November 2004, has been filled with effect from 2 December 2004 by
the appointment of Ms N F Mazibuko.
TABLINGS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- The Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development
(a) Report on the removal from office of Magistrate P W Phiri on
account of his incapacity to carry out his duties of office
efficiently.
(b) Proclamation No R.58 published in Government Gazette No 28990
dated 19 November 2004: Amendment of Proclamation in terms of the
Special Investigating Units and Special Tribunals Act, 1996 (Act
No 74 of 1996).
(c) Proclamation No R.59 published in Government Gazette No 28990
dated 19 November 2004: Referral of matters to existing Special
Investigating Unit and Special Tribunal in terms of the Special
Investigating Units and Special Tribunals Act, 1996 (Act No 74 of
1996).
THURSDAY, 3 FEBRUARY 2005
ANNOUNCEMENTS
National Council of Provinces
- Referrals to committees of papers tabled
The following papers have been tabled and are now referred to the
relevant committees as mentioned below:
(1) The following papers are referred to the Select Committee on
Finance:
(a) Activity Report of the Auditor-General for 2003-2004 [RP
211-2004].
(b) Special Report of the Auditor-General on the delays in the
tabling of Annual Reports and Consolidated Financial
Statements of National Government for 2003-2004 [RP 208-2004].
(c) General Report of the Auditor-General on the Audit Outcome
for 2003-2004 [RP 210-2004].
(d) Report and Financial Statements of the Financial Services
Board on the Registrar of Friendly Societies for 2003.
(e) Report and Financial Statements of the Government
Employees Pension Fund for 2002-2003, including the Report of
the Independent Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2002-
2003 [RP 1-2004].
(f) Government Notice No R1289 published in Government Gazette
No 26938 dated 5 November 2004: Determination of amounts in
terms of sections 1 and 5 of the Military Pensions Act, 1976
(Act No 84 of 1976).
(g) Government Notice No R1334 published in Government Gazette
No 26981 dated 19 November 2004: Exemption of Telkom SA
Limited and its subsidiaries and any entities under its
ownership control in terms of section 92 of the Public Finance
Management Act, 1999 (Act No 1 of 1999).
(h) Government Notice No R1353 published in Government Gazette
No 27011 dated 19 November 2004: Amendments to the exemptions
made in Government Gazette No 24176 dated 20 December 2003, in
terms of section 74 of the Financial Intelligence Centre Act,
2001 (Act No 38 of 2001).
(i) Government Notice No R1354 published in Government Gazette
No 27011 dated 19 November 2004: Second Reporting Exemption in
terms of the Financial Intelligence Centre Act, 2001 (Act No
38 of 2001).
(j) Government Notice No R1354 published in Government Gazette
No 27012 dated 19 November 2004: Amendment of prescribed fees,
made in terms of section 36 of the Pension Funds Act, 1956
(Act No 24 of 1956).
(2) The following paper is referred to the Select Committee on Land
and Environmental Affairs for consideration:
The following person has been appointed by Cabinet as a member and
chairperson of the South African National Parks Board, in terms of
section 8 of the National Parks Act, 1976 (Act No 57 of 1976):
(3) The following papers are referred to the Select Committee on
Land and Environmental Affairs:
(a) Report and Financial Statements of Mhlathuze Water Board
for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(b) Report and Financial Statements of the Sedibeng Water
Board for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(c) Report and Financial Statements of the Ikangala Water
Board for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(d) Report and Financial Statements of the Lepelle Water Board
for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(e) Report and Financial Statements of the Magalies Water
Board for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(f) Report and Financial Statements of the Rand Water Board
for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(g) Report and Financial Statements of the Bushbuckridge Water
Board for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(h) Report and Financial Statements of the Umgeni Water Board
for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(i) Report and Financial Statements of the Overberg Water
Board for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(j) Report and Financial Statements of the Botshelo Water
Board for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(k) Report and Financial Statements of the Bloem Water Board
for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(l) Report and Financial Statements of the Pelladrift Water
Board for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(m) Report and Financial Statements of the Namaqua Water Board
for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(n) Report and Financial Statements of the Amatola Water Board
for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(o) Report and Financial Statements of the Albany Coast Water
Board for 2003-2004, including the Report of the Independent
Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(p) Report and Financial Statements of the South African
Weather Service for 2002-2003, including the Report of the
Auditor-General on the Financial Statements for 2002-2003 [RP
221-2003].
(q) Report and Financial Statements of the South African
Weather Service for 2003-2004, including the Report of the
Auditor-General on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004 [RP
176-2004].
(r) Government Notice No 2483 published in Government Gazette
No 26969 dated 5 November 2004: Invitation to apply for
experimental longline fishing permits for the catching of
Patagonian tooth fish (Dissostichus SPP), tabled in terms of
the Marine Living Resources Act, 1998 (Act No 18 of 1998).
(s) Government Notice No 1135 published in Government Gazette
No 26848 dated 8 October 2004: Establishment of the
Ventersdorp-Dolomite Water User Association, Magisterial
district of Coligny, Koster, Lichtenburg and Ventersdorp, in
the North West Province, Water Management Area number 9 in
terms of the National Water Act, 1998 (Act No 36 of 1998).
(t) Government Notice No 1136 published in Government Gazette
No 26848 dated 8 October 2004: Transformation of the Elands
Valley Irrigation Board, Magisterial districts of Belfast,
Waterval Boven and Nelspruit, Mpumalanga Province, into the
Elands River Catchment Area number 5, Mpumalanga Province in
terms of the National Water Act, 1998 (Act No 36 of 1998).
(u) Government Notice No 1138 published in Government Gazette
No 26848 dated 8 October 2004: Restrictions on the taking of
water from the Tosca Molopo Dolomite Aquifer in terms of the
National Water Act, 1998 (Act No 36 of 1998).
(v) Government Notice No 1316 published in Government Gazette
No 26962 dated 12 November 2004: Proposal for the
Establishment of the Crocodile (West)- Marico Catchment
Management Agency in terms of section 78(3) of the National
Water Act, 1998 (Act No 36 of 1998).
(w) Government Notice No 2478 published in Government Gazette
No 26962 dated 12 November 2004: Prohibition on the making of
fires in the open air: Districts of Clanwilliam, Piketberg,
Ceres, Tulbagh, Worcester, Caledon, Paarl, Stellenbosch,
Strand and Somerset West in terms of the National Forests Act,
1998 (Act No 84 of 1998).
(x) Government Notice No 2479 published in Government Gazette
No 26962 dated 12 November 2004: Prohibition on the making of
fires in the open air: Districts of Swellendam and Montagu in
terms of the National Forests Act, 1998 (Act No 84 of 1998).
(y) Government Notice No 2480 published in Government Gazette
No 26962 dated 12 November 2004: Prohibition on the making of
fires in the open air: Western Cape in terms of the National
Forests Act, 1998 (Act No 84 of 1998).
(4) The following paper is referred to the Portfolio Committee on
Labour and Public Enterprises:
Report and Financial Statements of the South African Forestry
Company Limited for 2003-2004, including the Report of the
Independent-Auditors on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004.
(5) The following papers are referred to the Select Committee on
Security and Constitutional Affairs and the Joint Standing
Committee on Defence:
(a) The President of the Republic submitted a letter dated 26
November 2004 to the Chairperson of the National Council of
Provinces informing Members of the National Council of
Provinces of the employment of a member of the South African
National Defence Force in Mozambique.
(b) The President of the Republic submitted a letter dated 3
December 2004 to the Speaker of the Chairperson of the
National Council of Provinces informing Members of the
National Council of Provinces of the employment of members of
the South African National Defence Force in Mozambique.
(c) The Acting President of the Republic submitted a letter
dated 10 January 2005 to the Chairperson of the National
Council of Provinces informing Members of the National Council
of Provinces of the employment of the South African National
Defence Force in Sudan.
(6) The following paper is referred to the Select Committee on
Public Services:
Report and Financial Statements of the South African Rail Commuter
Corporation Limited (SARCC) for 2003-2004, including the Report of
the Auditor-General on the Financial Statements for 2003-2004 [RP
105-2004].
(7) The following paper is referred to the Select Committee on
Security and Constitutional Affairs for consideration and report:
Report on the removal from office of Magistrate P W Phiri on
account of his incapacity to carry out his duties of office
efficiently.
(8) The following papers are referred to the Select Committee on
Security and Constitutional:
(a) Proclamation No R.58 published in Government Gazette No
28990 dated 19 November 2004: Amendment of Proclamation in
terms of the Special Investigating Units and Special Tribunals
Act, 1996 (Act No 74 of 1996).
(b) Proclamation No R.59 published in Government Gazette No
28990 dated 19 November 2004: Referral of matters to existing
Special Investigating Unit and Special Tribunal in terms of
the Special Investigating Units and Special Tribunals Act,
1996 (Act No 74 of 1996).
TABLINGS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- The Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development
(a) Report on the provisional suspension from office of Magistrate R
Ameer.
(b) Report on the provisional suspension from office of Magistrate M
S Makamu.
(c) Report on the provisional suspension from office of Senior
Magistrate M J S Nhleko.
(d) Report on the provisional suspension from office of Magistrate M
K Chauke.
(e) Report on the provisional suspension from office of Magistrate L
D Monageng.
MONDAY, 7 FEBRUARY 2005
ANNOUNCEMENTS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- Introduction of Bills
(1) The Minister for Provincial and Local Government
(i) Intergovernmental Relations Framework Bill [B 3 - 2005]
(National Assembly - sec 75) [Explanatory summary of Bill and
prior notice of its introduction published in Government
Gazette No 27031 of 26 November 2004.]
Introduction and referral to the Portfolio Committee on Provincial
and Local Government of the National Assembly, as well as referral
to the Joint Tagging Mechanism (JTM) for classification in terms
of Joint Rule 160, on 7 February 2005.
In terms of Joint Rule 154 written views on the classification of
the Bill may be submitted to the Joint Tagging Mechanism (JTM)
within three parliamentary working days.
National Council of Provinces
- Referrals to committees of papers tabled
The following papers have been tabled and are now referred to the
relevant committees as mentioned below:
(1) The following papers are referred to the Select Committee on
Security and Constitutional Affairs for consideration and report:
(a) Report on the provisional suspension from office of
Magistrate R Ameer.
(b) Report on the provisional suspension from office of
Magistrate M S Makamu.
(c) Report on the provisional suspension from office of Senior
Magistrate M J S Nhleko.
(d) Report on the provisional suspension from office of
Magistrate M K Chauke.
(e) Report on the provisional suspension from office of
Magistrate L D Monageng.
TABLINGS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- The Speaker and the Chairperson
(a) Report of the Auditor-General on the Financial Statements of the
Citrus Board for 2001-2002 [RP 204-2004].
(b) Report of the Auditor-General on the Financial Statements of the
Meat Board for the year ended 31 December 2001 [RP 196-2004].
(c) Report of the Auditor-General on the Financial Statements of the
President's Fund for 2002-2003 [RP 84-2004].
(d) Report of the Auditor-General on the Financial Statements of the
Special Pensions Board for 2003-2004 [RP 193-2004].
- The Minister of Finance
(a) Government Notice No 1474 published in Government Gazette No
27124 dated 23 December 2004: Adjusted allocations in terms of the
Division of Revenue Act, 2004 (Act No 5 of 2004).
(b) Proclamation No R.62 published in Government Gazette No 27139
dated 22 December 2004: Fixing of date on which sections 121(1)
and 148(1)(e) of the Second Revenue Laws Amendment Act, 2001 (Act
No 60 of 2001), and section 164(1)(c), (i) and (j), sections
169(1)(e) and section 170(1)(b) of the Revenue Laws Amendment Act,
2003 (Act No 45 of 2003), shall come into operation in terms of
the Second Revenue Laws Amendment Act, 2001 (Act No 60 of 2001)
and Revenue laws Amendment act, 2003 (Act No 45 of 2003).
(c) Government Notice No 1429 published in Government Gazette No
27070 dated 10 December 2004: Notice fixing amount of tax in
dispute for purposes of appeal to Tax Board in terms of section
83A of the Income Tax Act, 1962 and section 33A of the Value-Added
Tax Act, 1991 in terms of the Income Tax Act, 1962 (Act No 58 of
1962).
(d) Government Notice No 1432 published in Government Gazette No
27077 dated 10 December 2004: Notice setting out particulars of
areas demarcated by Municipalities of Ethekwini, Tshwane,
Emfuleni, Sol Plaatje, Manguang, Buffalo City and Mbombela in
terms of section 13quat of the Income Tax Act, 1962 (Act No 58 of
1962), which shall constitute urban development zones.
(e) Government Notice No 1404 published in Government Gazette No
27044 dated 1 December 2004: Exemptions from supply chain
management provisions in terms of the Local Government: Municipal
Finance Management Act, 2003 (Act No 56 of 2003).
(f) Government Notice No 1405 published in Government Gazette No
27044 dated 1 December 2004: Amendment of Government Notice No 773
dated 1 July 2004 in terms of the Local Government: Municipal
Finance Management Act, 2003 (Act No 56 of 2003).
(g) Government Notice No 1433 published in Government Gazette No
27084 dated 8 December 2004: Approval of allocations in terms of
the Division of Revenue Act, 2004 (Act No 5 of 2004).
h) Discussion Paper on Retirement Fund Reform.
TUESDAY, 8 FEBRUARY 2005
ANNOUNCEMENTS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- Membership of Committees
(1) The following changes have been effected to the Joint
Committees, viz:
Budget:
Appointed: Burgess, Mr C V
Defence:
Appointed: Burgess, Mr C V
Discharged: Jankielsohn, Mr R; Sinclair, Mr K
Improvement of Quality of Life and Status of Children, Youth and
Disabled Persons:
Appointed: Gore, Mr V C
Improvement of Quality of Life and Status of Women:
Appointed: Batyi, Ms F; Camerer, Ms S M (Alt); Mdlalose, Ms M M
(Alt)
TABLINGS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- The Speaker and the Chairperson
Supplementary Submission of the Financial and Fiscal Commission on the
Division of Revenue Bill for 2005-2006 and the Medium Term Expenditure
Framework (MTEF) for 2005-2008, tabled in terms of section 9(1) of the
Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations Act, 1997 (Act No 97 of 1997).
National Council of Provinces
- The Chairperson
(a) Progress report on the intervention in Elundini Municipality in
terms of section 139 of the Constitution, from the MEC for
Housing, Local Government and Traditional Affairs in the Eastern
Cape.
To be referred to the Select Committee on Local Government and
Administration for consideration.
(b) The President of the Republic submitted the following letter
dated 27 January 2005 to the Chairperson of the National Council
of Provinces of the employment of the South African National
Defence Force in the Democratic Republic of Congo:
EMPLOYMENT OF THE SOUTH AFRICAN NATIONAL DEFENCE FORCE IN THE
DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF CONGO, FOR SERVICE IN FULFILLMENT OF THE
INTERNATIONAL OBLIGATIONS OF THE REPUBLIC OF SOUTH AFRICA TOWARDS
THE DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF CONGO
This serves to inform the National Council of Provinces that I
authorised the employment of the South African National Defence
Force (SANDF) personnel to the Democratic Republic of Congo, for
service in fulfillment of the international obligations of the
Republic of South Africa towards the Democratic Republic of Congo
in the provision of support in the integration and training of the
new restructured forces.
This employment was authorised in accordance with the provisions
of section 201(2)(c) of the Constitution of the Republic of South
Africa, 1996 (Act No 108 of 1996), read with section 93 of the
Defence Act, 2002 (Act No 42 of 2002).
A total of 40 members are employed as from mid-January 2005 for a
period of 12 months.
The total estimated cost to be borne by South Africa for the
deployment of personnel is R 25 600 036.
I will communicate this report to the Members of the National
Assembly and the Chairperson of the Joint Standing Committee on
Defence, and wish to request that you bring the contents hereof to
the notice of the National Council of Provinces.
Regards
SIGNED
T M MBEKI
PRESIDENT
THURSDAY, 10 FEBRUARY 2005
ANNOUNCEMENTS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- Assent by President in respect of Bills
(1) Water Services Amendment Bill [B 17 - 2004] - Act No 30 of 2004
(assented to and signed by President on 7 February 2005);
(2) National Environmental Management: Protected Areas Amendment
Bill [B 2B - 2004] - Act No 31 of 2004 (assented to and signed by
President on 7 February 2005);
(3) Protection of Constitutional Democracy against Terrorist and
Related Activities Bill [B 12F - 2003] - Act No 33 of 2004
(assented to and signed by President on 4 February 2005).
(4) Traditional Health Practitioners Bill [B 66B - 2003] - Act No 35
of 2004 (assented to and signed by President on 7 February 2005);
(5) Financial Services Ombud Schemes Bill [B 20B - 2004] - Act No 37
of 2004 (assented to and signed by President on 4 February 2005);
and
(6) Choice on Termination of Pregnancy Amendment Bill [B 72D - 2003]
- Act No 38 of 2004 (assented to and signed by President on 4
February 2005).
TABLINGS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- The Minister in The Presidency
Strategic Plan of Government Communication and Information System
(GCIS) for 2005-2008.
- The Minister of Trade and Industry
(a) Bilateral Trade Agreement between the Government of the Republic
of South Africa and the Government of the Republic of Croatia,
tabled in terms of section 231(3) of the Constitution, 1996.
(b) Explanatory Memorandum of the Bilateral Trade Agreement between
the Government of the Republic of South Africa and the Government
of the Republic of Croatia.
TUESDAY, 15 FEBRUARY 2005
ANNOUNCEMENTS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- Introduction of Bills
(1) The Minister of Trade and Industry
(i) Co-operatives Bill [B 4 - 2005] (National Assembly - sec
75) [Explanatory summary of Bill and prior notice of its
introduction published in Government Gazette No 27257 of 4
February 2005.]
Introduction and referral to the Portfolio Committee on Trade
and Industry of the National Assembly, as well as referral to
the Joint Tagging Mechanism (JTM) for classification in terms
of Joint Rule 160, on 14 February 2005.
In terms of Joint Rule 154 written views on the classification
of the Bill may be submitted to the Joint Tagging Mechanism
(JTM) within three parliamentary working days.
(ii) Close Corporations Amendment Bill [B 6 - 2005] (National
Assembly - sec 75) [Explanatory summary of Bill and prior
notice of its introduction published in Government Gazette No
27281 of 11 February 2005.]
Introduction and referral to the Portfolio Committee on Trade
and Industry of the National Assembly, as well as referral to
the Joint Tagging Mechanism (JTM) for classification in terms
of Joint Rule 160, on 16 February 2005.
In terms of Joint Rule 154 written views on the classification
of the Bill may be submitted to the Joint Tagging Mechanism
(JTM) within three parliamentary working days.
(2) The Minister for Justice and Constitutional Development
(i) Citation of Constitutional Laws Bill [B 5 - 2005]
(National Assembly - sec 75) [Explanatory summary of Bill and
prior notice of its introduction published in Government
Gazette No 27278 of 10 February 2005.]
Introduction and referral to the Portfolio Committee on
Justice and Constitutional Development of the National
Assembly, as well as referral to the Joint Tagging Mechanism
(JTM) for classification in terms of Joint Rule 160, on 15
February 2005.
In terms of Joint Rule 154 written views on the classification
of the Bill may be submitted to the Joint Tagging Mechanism
(JTM) within three parliamentary working days.
- Draft bills submitted in terms of Joint Rule 159
(1) South African Abattoir Corporation Act Repeal Bill, 2005,
submitted by the Minister for Agriculture and Land Affairs on 4
February 2005. Referred to the Portfolio Committee on Agriculture
and Land Affairs and the Select Committee on Land and
Environmental Affairs.
TABLINGS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- The Minister of Home Affairs
The Employment Equity Report of the Independent Electoral Commission
for 2003, tabled in terms of section 22 of the Employment Equity Act,
1998 (Act No 55 of 1998).
National Council of Provinces
- The Chairperson
Notice received from the MEC for Local Government and Housing in the
Mpumalanga Province regarding the intervention in the Thaba Chweu Local
Municipality in terms of section 139(1)(b) of the Constitution of the
Republic of South Africa (Act No 108 of 1996).
Referred to the Select Committee on Local Government and Administration
for consideration and report.
WEDNESDAY, 16 FEBRUARY 2005
TABLINGS
National Assembly and National Council of Provinces
- The Minister of Finance
Municipal Investment Regulations and Municipal Public-Private
Partnership Regulations, in terms of section 168 of the Municipal
Finance Management Act, 2003 (Act No 56 of 2003).
[1] The SAWEN contact person is Ms Lindiwe Ncobo at 086 110 1968 or 083 303 1697